relweb.gif (3799 bytes)     
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1996 Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

.

Pain and Emotion transferrance - Damaged Shields

Over the years, and after several abusive relationships, including some with members of my own family, I have come to realize, with healing and inner searching, that I am a pretty okay person. I'm not addicted to drama or crisis, when I'm by myself I'm a happy, content person. I am a very sensitive and caring person, so when I'm around someone that is hurting, or feeling some strong emotions, I tend to become empathetic with them.

I just wonder if on some other level of conciousness, if people who are miserable seek out people who are like me, sensitive, caring, etc... (or who knows, visa versa)? I have noticed in my experience, that after a while, when I've spent some time with people who are miserable, that I myself start to become miserable. And I've also noticed that some of the things these people do, verbally, physically, would cause such an obviously painful reaction in anyone. Here is just a fictional example: Someone drops a book on their foot, and it is painful, but because they lack certain communication skills, rather than talk to their partner about the pain and embarrassment, they walk up to the partner and drop a book on THEIR foot, just so they can 'see how it feels to hurt like they do'. So on a more extreme level, if people are miserable and lack the skills to communicate and heal, then it seems to me that they do everything in their power to cause their partner to feel just as miserable as they do, just to show them, "See, that's how I feel inside."

This is basic in alot of situations, and a reason why there are abusive people in the world. They are acting out how they were treated as children and young adults, and it's a big chain reaction. It goes so far back it's almost scary.

I just feel inside, that to an angry, miserable person, because I'm a happy, loving person, I remind them of the child they were once, a long time ago, and it either makes them jealous that I'm a kind, gentle person, or it makes them want to destroy my 'child-like' attitude, the same way their's was destroyed when they were a child.

I've had it rough throughout my life, including my childhood, but somehow I've managed to hang onto that pure, 'full of life' attitude. Everyone can mope around, bitching and moaning and complaining of how harsh the world is, and how society is out to get them, etc... but I choose to see the sunlight, and listen to the birds sing, and laugh and smile and play, even while I'm working 40 hours a week, and dealing with grumpy people on a daily basis. I still find time to enjoy who I am and find pleasure in life.

What's with these miserable people? And why do they choose to transfer their dismalities onto others? If they know how bad it hurts to be hurting then why would they want to do it to someone else? Should we just walk away from people like this? Should we try to help them? If we ignore them, and they don't get better, then won't they transfer their misery onto their children and just keep creating generations of grumpy miserable people?

Thanks for letting me share, it's been on my mind.

From: Bernd

Your insights hit a lot of echoes inside me. Here's a few of my guesses to some of your questions.

My guess is that we do things because they work better than anything else we’ve discovered. When people around us aren’t willing to share our pain or show empathy and compassion willingly, then we use what we’ve learned from others’ example - we FORCE the issue, to try to get what we want and need.

And yes, we DO get some comfort - probably all the comfort we feel we are able to - from knowing that the other person hurts as much as us.

An emotionally abusive person has developed a very finely tuned radar that can pick up where the sore spots of their victim are. The more healed a person is, the less emotional abuse “works”, because those sore spots are much harder to find - and when they DO find them, the recovering person has more of an awareness that they are usually old wounds the abuser is picking at, not new ones they’re creating.

Emotional abuse works because it rips open buried hidden beliefs about ourself that are wrapped in old pain. If someone calls me stupid, it doesn’t cause me pain unless somewhere inside I believe that, and believe it’s a bad thing, or that it makes me less lovable. If I call you an apple, it doesn’t do hardly anything, because you don’t have any doubt that you AREN’T an apple, and even if you were, being an apple is ok!:)

But if I call you ugly, or fat, for most women this strikes a deep nerve, because beauty and ugliness is a struggle many women deal with deep inside, and being “ugly” definitely puts a woman’s “lovability” at a disadvantage in our society.

An abuser knows as well when our minds and our hidden beliefs don’t ring in harmony. We may convince ourselves consciously that we are beautiful, or say that “beauty is on the inside as well as the outside”, but inside we are still terrified of being “ugly”.

The irony is, in my opinion, that the abuser’s words have a ring of truth to them, which is what gives them the ability to cut thru our defenses like butter. I AM ugly and beautiful - both at the same time. Inside and outside. And ugliness can be a bad thing, or a good thing. It is really neutral; it depends on how I use it, and how I view it. Like water, I can either use water to quench my thirst, and give me life, or I can drown in it.

Not only is it ok for me to be ugly, but I can rejoice in it. It helps me look into the disfigured face of a burn victim, and have their face fill me with wonder and magic. Why would I want to deprive myself of that?

Being comfortable with my own ugliness brings me to the next step. Whatever I’m “okay with” in myself, I’m “okay with” in others. I can’t fake this, and when I do, an abusive person will always be able to ferret out what I truly believe inside, and what I “think” I believe.

To me, the we are only able to give the kind of compassion and empathy an abusive person is REALLY looking for when we are able to be okay with the ugliness inside THEM. And THEY feel that ugliness, because they keep trying to slice it out of their souls, by dumping it on others. If you really want to make an abusive person feel the pain of what they are doing, there is no surer way than by responding with acceptance and compassion. Genuine love is a mirror that terrifies someone who is trying to send out pain, because it gives them an unmistakable reflection of how much they are hurting themselves in doing so.

An almost final thought. I don’t believe happiness is the absence of pain. I believe it includes a real willingness to share the suffering and pain of others at the deepest levels. To be able to do so, we have to be first willing to feel our own suffering and pain at those deep levels, and be able to STAY with that suffering and pain. It’s only by embracing it that it becomes transformed, and we no longer feel the need or urge to run from it.

Sound impossible or hard? I think we do this naturally every time we watch a tear-jerker movie. We cry, we feel for those suffering in the movie, but yet we LIKE this kind of pain. It feels different, alive, and it transforms us. We are drawn to the next movie that generates the same kinds of feelings in us. We also do this at funerals, and quite willingly.

Now the final thought. The line “love your enemies” doesn’t mean we should cooperate in letting them hurt us, because if we do so, it means we cooperate in helping them hurt themselves as well. To me, it means recognizing that the amount of love I have for myself is still very incomplete, and so the amount of love I can give to those that try to hurt me is also incomplete. Accepting this also means I don’t try to give more love than I’m capable of, and admit when I’m unable to handle a certain level of abuse. If I’m honest about what I can handle and what I can’t, I find I can make better choices about how close or how far I need to be, in my relationship with an abuser. I find that my choices get better with time, and those choices are helped because I’m judging the abuser less, and discovering more of the sore spots on me they’ve uncovered.

Whatever hopes I have that they’ll “change” are being taken care of without any extra work on my part. They notice acutely when someone has found a way to deal with their attempts in healthier ways. They notice, and puzzle about it. The little voice inside them whispers a bit louder, and they find it harder to quiet it down. They become more aware that their gameplan isn’t as foolproof as they once thought, and that the other person is getting more of what they wanted all along - freedom from a cage of pain and confusion inside. Nothing you can do to an abusive person - striking back, leaving them, putting them in jail, etc. - will generate more suffering in them than the realization you’ve found a path that brings you closer to heaven, while they’re still stuck in hell. Nothing. Absolutely nothing.

My 2 bits, for what they’re worth.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.