relweb.gif (3799 bytes)     
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1996 Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

.

Controlling men - Karen

My boyfriend of 2 years is very insecure. He believes all women fool around and will end up hurting him. My problem is that he doesn't want me spending any time with my children's father, who I am still legally married to. The kids wanted to go to an amusement park but their father didn't want to go alone so he asked me. I said yes but when I told my boyfriend he said if I go then he doesn't want to see me anymore. Is he right to make this demand on me. I didn't end up going but I feel very angry about the whole thing. He says I don't need to see or talk to him unless it is of great importance to do with the kids. Please someone respond. I really need advise. Secondly how do you know if a man is a control freak.

From: HammerTime

I would say that your boyfriend has been "pursuing" you for the last 2 years. I don't mean to be harsh or rude here, but when pursuing something it looks a hell of alot better than if you were not pursuing it. The forbidden fruit. The cookie you can't have. Get the point? My guess is that he would not be so interested in your relationship if there was no other man involved. Matter of fact, you just might become very unappealing to him and he may lose interest.

On the other hand, I may be wrong. Maybe he really loves you and wants to be with you, but why are you still legally married after 2 years? Maybe he has a right to be jealous and impatient. I know I would if my girlfriend of 2 years was still married to someone she supposedly doesn't love anymore.

From: Karen

I've known this man for 10 yrs. He doesn't like me going out with the girls, which I have no desire to, all my time is with him outside of my children. He has a good relationship with them also. To answer your question. My husband never did much as a family and doesn't go on much rides, so if I tagged along I could go on the adult rides with my daughter, he doesn't go on any rides. This isn't a case of now he has me and now he doesn't want me. I'm just trying to understand where he's coming from. He knows where I am 24hrs a day and if a few hours goes by and he doesn't get a hold of me, he starts phoning around looking for me, and if he doesn't find me he will leave a somewhat rude message on my answering machine. My ex-husband is usually not an issue in our relationship. Everything else is.

From: Kim

I have been in a very similar circumstance. It was strange because my marriage of 13 years was very trusting and very uncontrolling. We may have had problems, but his not trusting me was not one of them.

However, after my marriage ended I got involved with someone who "looked after me" when I really needed it, but couldn't stop trying to control me after I didn't need quite so much support. He accused me of things I would never ever do and also didn't want me to be with or talk with my ex. It got to the point that I was afraid that if he called and I didn't get right to the phone he was going to blast me, or if he called and I was on the phone he'd want to know who I was talking to and why I even wanted to talk with them. I became very isolated and basically lost my personality. Thank God he dumped me because I was so strapped to him emotionally that I don't think I could have let go on my own.

Be very careful. This guy is obviously very insecure and you can't "fix" someone with those kinds of hang-ups. He has to want to fix himself and then do it himself. No matter how you try to appease him, in the end it won't work, because it's not about you, it's about his neediness and insecurity. Good luck!

From: Bernd

I agree. When a partner doesn't support your right to make your own choices freely, and try to talk out their insecurities with you to come to win/win solutions, then control is very much at work. No one wins. In a poker game, the one that bluff's best usually ends up controlling the game. What is worth more: your own peace of mind, or the "relationship"? If it's the first, do what feels right and good for you, and give him the right to have whatever feelings he has, and do whatever he chooses (such as leave), unless his choices force harm on you - such as stalking, abuse, etc.

This man is capable of loving an obedient pet, but not another human being in a true intimate relationship. Not right now anyway. If you stay, doing what is best for YOU, will also be best for him, no matter how much he hates it or tries to persuade you otherwise. My thoughts anyway.

From: Karen

Funny thing is he has dumped me and I've gone back to him, even though I don't feel good about myself for being so weak, I still do it. He says he loves me but this I also have a problem with. We have no couples we hang out with. Every minute I get away from my children it's spent with him. I'm so insecure about our relationship that I've come to the conclusion to not be so much a part of his life, or his mine. I've joined a gym in the last week trying to take up a lot of my free time, because if he decides to leave me again, I want to have something to fall back on. If you can understand me. In the last 2 years of being with him I don't feel very good about myself as I didn't with my husband. I have a good job, I'm attractive and smart, so knowing this why would I let him treat me this way, why don't I tell him to leave. I wish I could answer this question.

From: Bernd

Karen, the book "Women Who Love Too Much" gave me a lot of insight as to why I was doing things in our relationship which kept causing me pain. The book could just as well be called "People who love too much". I'd highly recommend it.

If you feel okay doing so, maybe telling us more about your childhood, and your parent's relationship, might help shed light on the influences that would have been impressed deeply inside you as a child. Those would show up a lot in the way you feel, but run so deep our "logical" mind has a lot of difficulty understanding their impact on our current lives.

From: Me

Hogwash. Karen does not need to tell us anything about her childhood or parents. This may be something she wants to keep to herself. I'm sick of these so called psychologists who think everything stems from some deep dark secret in their childhood. I've seen people who were raised with great morals and ended up with no morals at all. And vice-versa. I've seen people who had a terrible childhood and then had a terrible adulthood. Karen, you just leave those precious memories to yourself and away from the privy noses of these hungry psychologists.

Your relationship is about two insecure people who are holding on to each other afraid they would never find anyone else. Your best bet, let this guy go. He is holding you down and keeping you from making real friends. Joining the gym was a great idea. If you are interested in meeting other guys then I suggest joining a work-out club (unless that's what you already mean by gym). There you can find many people who also have a life and enjoy taking care of their bodies. From what you have told us, I seriously doubt either of you are in love with the other. He is too possessive and insecure. You are afraid to let him go because right now he is your security. Get out there and boost your esteem! Meet some guys! Make friends! And soon you will realize what a dweeb your boyfriend is.

From: Karen

Thanks for your comments and I agree my childhood isn't the root to everyone's problems. People sometimes create their own problems without anything to do with their past. Looking at your past is not always the answer. I'm a firm believer that concentrating on your future is the best medicine even if you have skeletons in the closet. I truly believe I love this man, but there's not a lot of thing I like about him. I don't think he would ever physically abuse me but sometimes the way he distrusts me makes me sick. Joining the gym was an outlet from him. I don't think I did it to meet men because I meet also through work but I do feel like I need something more in my life. I really can't see myself with someone else but who knows maybe that will change.

From: Me

One final thought Karen. You say that you truly love him. I realize that love can come many different forms, but it's my opinion that "true" love, the kind that lasts, has to be directed towards your best friend. Is this man your best friend? If he is not, then the wise thing to do would be keeping your heart open to others. Friends first, lovers second.

From: Karen

to answer your question, NO, he is not my best friend. If I tell him something that I don't want him to tell anyone else, I can't be sure if he'll tell another. Let me give you an example. I hope I can say this on this forum. He tells me to be open with him sexually, and if I don't he wont know what pleases me. Even though I have a hard time, I end up telling him what's on my mind. When we engage in Sex and I touch him in order to him going, he always wants to get right into intercourse. He won't try to get me horny. He says if after I touch him and he gets an erection, if he stimulates me he will lose his erection. I'm sorry but I have a hard time with this. I vision 2 people making love but need foreplay before and this includes touching, caressing, kissing. I tell him that having intercourse just doesn't do it for me and I need some other things before. His response is that I'm selfish(he's laughing when he tells me this) and that he has spoiled me because going down on me once in a while should be good enough. Oh by the way when he does this it is great but sometimes he doesn't and expects me to get horny feeling him and him not doing the same. "WHY IS HE THIS WAY"

From: Me

Although this isn't quite what I meant by being a best friend I can still answer your question on this matter. Lovemaking as well as loving in a relationship is about giving. It is about wanting to please your partner. Sexually, it is about making your partner feel alive and beautiful. He is more concerned about pleasing himself rather than pleasing you. In a loving relationship, each partner is more concerned about pleasing the other. So my initial observation is that he does not love you. Actually I have already said this before. As an outsider my opinion is that neither of you are in a loving relationship.

I can use only my girlfriend as an example. In bed, as well as in life, I only want to please her. Her getting me excited is only an afterthought simply because turning her on also turns me on. If she is not happy then neither am I. The funny thing is, when I concentrate on getting her going, she wants to turn me on in return. It is a giving act. So by giving you also get in return. Needless to say, she has an orgasm 99% of the time. That's the way it should be.

From: Karen

Hi everyone, I just thought I would get on the forum and give a little update to my situation. On my last listing I discussed my problem with my controlling boyfriend. It has been 2-3 weeks now and I am still going to the gym on a regular basis, unfortunately things are still the same with him. He doesn't like the fact that I go almost every day, he says I'm loosing to much weight, which I'm not (I've gone down I pant size.) The weekend that just past I finally went away to Belleville to stay with a girlfriend. We went out I had a terrible time and came back the Saturday. I called him on Friday night, he got mad and ended up going out himself to a bar. Went away Saturday so I didn't see him until he called me at home Saturday night at 12:00 Midnight. He's now saying that if I go to the gym for even an 1 1\2 when I don't have the kids, he will go and do whatever even if its the whole day. I try to tell him its only for an hour and that after I'm done we will do something. This isn't good enough, either I don't go and do something with him, or I go and spend the rest of the day or maybe even weekend by myself. What do I DO WITH HIM. My guess is that he is only going to get worse. He now says I'm fine the way I am but I don't feel like that.

From: Lady "G"

Believe me there are a lot of men out there that are like yours. What is it with them? They're afraid of losing you, that's what it is. They think just because you go to the gym, you're there to check out the musclemania, but it's really for your health, right? Your man must not have a hobby because he sounds like he's bored . He tells you you're fine the way you are because he doesn't want you to be away, but it doesn't matter whether a person is skinny or fat, going to the gym improves your health, so keep up the good workout!!!

From: Bernd

When one person in a codependent relationship begins making choices that are healthier for them, the struggles in the relationship almost ALWAYS get worse, before they get better. I'll make another comparison to cars - whenever I try to fix something, I have to take it apart, and before I can put things back together again in ways that work better, what I have for a long while is just a bunch of pieces that look like wreckage around me. I fix what I can, and if I get too frustrated, I find a mechanic, or buy another car. (Ha, fat chance of THAT being a solution right now for me! *grin*)

Anyway, I digress.:) Back to the relationship. Things get worse because the dance has been changed, and the partner always tries to bring things back to the status quo, because it's familiar. We fear change, especially change that we seem to have no control over. Your partner's anger is how he's used to masking his fear.

Try to remind yourself that whatever is truly best for you, is best for him - even if it triggers old pain and struggle and anger in him. You didn't cause any of those; your healthy choices meant that he could no longer distract himself from feeling those, by his trying to control the part of your life that you now take to the gym. What he does with those feelings is up to him. Changing your choices to appease him means you become his valium, his drug.

How to cope with his anger and attempts to get you to go back to how you were before? In my opinion, the most important thing is to take the time you need with yourself (and talking to others) to find as much calmness and solidness as you can about your ownership of your body. Let him know that you are willing to talk with him to find win/win solutions. If he's willing to talk, that's great. If not, give him the freedom to do what he feels best for him (even if it's NOT what's best for him). I'd recommend letting him know as honestly as you can what you want from him, while giving him the freedom to do the same in expressing his needs. Give yourself permission to be totally illogical.

Try to stay away from a "if you do this, I'll do that" kind of struggle. The things that works best for me is reminding someone that I'll do what I need to to keep myself safe, and treat myself as a friend would. And I don't try to explain what I might do if a given situation arises, cause that's a trap (trying to predict what I'll do). I'll do what's best for me, if and when any moment arises where I need to look carefully at how someone's treating me. Anyhow, I'm starting to sound like a father hen, so I'll stop now.:)

Take what works, and leave the rest. I think it's great that you're doing something that makes YOU feel good, and is good for you, like the gym. I just thought of something - would your partner be up to a dare of a race around the local baseball field a few times a week, with the winner buying the loser (and themselves as well) their favorite flavor of ice cream after as a consolation prize? Would give him a workout too, and make your gym time part of the contest, and the play. Just a thought.:) Never know, eh???? You go girl!


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.