relweb.gif (3799 bytes)     
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1996 Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

.

Distancing by cheating - Kristine

Dear Bernd and ... ...all the guys (maybe women, too) who have used affairs--extra relationship as well as extra-marital--for the purpose of "distancing":

I have been reading the posts to this forum for about a week now and am very impressed with the way you all care for each other as well as the thoughtfulness of the writing. I am also experiencing a difficult relationship, though luckily, I'm in the beginning stages and can get out without major emotional upset, if I feel I have to. Unluckily, I'm the type who gets involved very deeply very quickly--and that's undoubtedly part of my problem.

I would like to know more about the use of extra-relationship affairs as a way to prevent or slow down intimacy. I am involved with a man who (as is usually the case) was absolutely marvellous to me at the beginning (around 6 mo. ago; we've known each other almost a year) but has subsequently started putting other women between us. He said I was coming on too strong (which, as I know myself pretty well, is no doubt true; except that he was if anything coming on stronger and faster) and he needed to see others. All this seems reasonable; after all, we're not committed to each other (neither of our divorces is final). But we're both in our 40's, and I especially want to understand better what makes this kind of situation tick, since my own marriage broke up because of my husband's affairs (not his--his wife has a mental illness, although one never knows the whole story), and I don't want to make the same mistake again. I know about how partners who attract each other often are working on similar psychological problems, and the chances are that even if this relationship doesn't become permanent someday, the next man in my life will be dealing with the same issue. Besides all this, I'm hurting like Hell over seeing him openly flirt with other women, sometimes even when I'm around.

Is it possible to tell early on whether a man is just trying to protect himself from an intimacy he has good reason to fear, or whether he's the type who will always cheat? One friend says that he's a jerk from the get-go, and I should move on. Except that when I have made starts to do this he seems upset, though he also looks like he is hiding his emotions. Another friend says wait--he just needs time to sort out his life; and this is certainly true, too. My daughter who, as the saying goes, is "12-going-on-30", says he's just "acting wild and stupid before he gets too old". Obviously, no matter how much I hurt, I have to wait and keep busy with other things, but I don't really feel like looking for someone else right now, as maybe a younger person would do automatically. Could those of you who have been through this give me your thoughts on this "distancing" thing? Are the feelings ever malicious?

I have never criticized or complained about anything he does or is, except I'm obviously jealous of the women (now two, although he claims I'm being "silly" about this one--that he's not trying to "get" her) and it's certainly not because of marital things like housework or raising kids. How do you tell if he's not one of the smooth-talking "seducer" types who uses one woman after another, but is just too guilt-ridden to dump me outright? BTW, I've looked at articles and Web pages about "affairs", but my case is not really about an affair, but just monogamy in a dating relationship. Nobody though, goes into the "distancing" issue as much as Bernd has. I'd just like to hear more.

From: Bernd

An affair is just one of the ways a person - male or female - uses to try to put the brakes on a slide into emptiness inside them. From what I’ve seen, it isn’t used so much as a way to create some distance in the relationship, as it is a desperate attempt to try to resolve the growing effects of the closeness/separateness struggle inside the unfaithful partner. In simple English, the unfaithful partner is feeling panicked and empty inside, and finds themselves drawn into the “new partner’s” com-hither signals like a moth to light.

Remember Snow White and the poison apple? What looked delicious and healthy almost killed her, because she didn’t know about the poison inside.

The real poison in an affair isn’t the intimacy with another person, or even the sex (though I know I’ll get lots of disagreement on this). It’s the fear of abandonment, the broken promises (spoken and unspoken), the ripping-to-shreds of the safety of future intimacy, and the dishonesty, and the need to convince the other partner that THEIR GUT FEELINGS ARE WRONG. When we lead someone down the garden path to NOT believing their inner voice, what we are doing essentially is convincing them not to trust their soul. We are using their trust and love for us to harm them to the core. That is why we hurt so damn much when we discover an affair. It’s like being convinced to leave our mom as a small child, and then finding out we’ve been used - and being terrified we’re separated from her forever. People who have had their trust in themselves ripped away are terrified they’ll ever be able to trust THEMSELVES again. By that I mean their ability to use their intuition and minds to spot danger and betrayal by ANYONE. That is very, very scary. And not being able to trust our inner voice IS dangerous, in a very real sense. (There are plenty of murdered abused women who had exactly this kind of struggle, not to mention people whose lives were put in real jeopardy by the “lovers’” plots to get rid of the unwanted spouse.) That doesn’t mean that the majority of unfaithful partners will want to physically harm their partners. But the more their spouse is out of touch with their inner voice, the more blindly that spouse is flying. Flying an airplane with your eyes closed at 20,000 ft feels just as scary as flying it at 500 ft., even though the actual chances of crashing into something are a lot different.

In my opinion, there is no person who will “always cheat”, although if a man or woman has been unfaithful once, the odds are that they won’t stop there - unless they’ve done some significant recovery work in the aftermath.

What leads a person to an affair? My best guess is that it’s a combination of factors. The struggle over the closeness/separateness issues certainly plays a big part. And ways we’ve learned to cope with pain and struggle from early childhood are usually of little help in dealing with this struggle. No one told us that something inside of us would feel terrified when our partner got too close or pulled away. We were taught by others’ example to “live with it”, “be a man (or woman)”, “take care of our responsibilities”. In other words, we were taught to stuff our feelings when they were ones we couldn’t seem to resolve any other way, such as talking to our partner. And we all grew up sensitive to other people’s judgements. We tiptoed carefully when we DID bring up more serious things with our partner, because the last thing we wanted to be labelled as was a “jerk, bastard, etc.” or a “bitch”.

So while all of us share our feelings and fears with our partner at some level, there’s other parts of us that are off limits. Not only to our partners, but we want to keep those closet doors of old pain and monsters locked away from OURSELVES. Except that love won’t allow that to happen. There is a power in love that UNDERSTANDS that shutting off parts of ourselves splits us. It cripples us. While we’re young and healthy, it doesn’t SEEM to affect our lives a whole lot. But it’s like AIDS - the dark sides of us - kept hidden - continue to rot away inside of us, and we hurt other people without being aware of it. When we cut ourselves off from parts of ourselves, we also cut ourselves off from much of the guidance of our inner voice as well.

So our love is trying to help our partner heal, but in doing so, it makes them MORE aware of old pain and emptiness. It FEELS like it’s HURTING them. Pile that on top of our OWN dysfunctional ways of relating, and our own anger at how their love is making those hidden parts of US feel, and you have the common relationship. One where, the closer the two partners get, and the longer they are together, the more struggles seem to pop out of nowhere. In the end you get the 50% national divorce rate, in addition to those marriages that stay together but are more like truces, than ongoing romances.

One of the things that Lynda and I found difficult was there weren’t many EXAMPLES around us of couples that took the past pain their relationship uncovered, and worked together to heal it - instead of blaming their partners for making them unhappy. How many couples do you know that are comfortable talking about THEIR problems with you, in ways that give you clear signs that they are committed to finding win/win solutions? We found few. The “appearance” we saw was almost everyone was happier inner relationships than us. We felt like misfits. I felt like a misfit, and a failure. The worse I felt, the less of a partner I was to Lynda, and the worse she felt. That left me feeling like even more of a failure. Eventually I felt so empty inside, that when a woman showed she was attracted enough to me, I took the doorway marked “affair”. Simply, I wanted to feel “love” without feeling pain, without struggle, even if only for a few brief moments. By the time I had each affair, I had shut down so much of myself inside to try and numb the old pain and emptiness that I my inner voice couldn’t get though to me even by screaming. Which it certainly tried to do.

There are men and women who have become very good at appearing perfectly normal while locking away painful past parts of themselves behind steel doors. There are good conmen (and conwomen) in all sorts of areas of life, and the area of love and relationships are no different. When someone finds someone “too good to be true”, warning bells always go off in me. If a potential partner IS genuinely healthy emotionally and spiritually, their inner voice is very much in the driver’s seat, and their inner voice will clue them in to the healing WE still need to do. As a result, their relationship with us will often be confusing and frustrating (and seem boring in many ways), because their way of relating will seem very foreign to us. Conpeople on the other hand are more like the poison apple. They have had experience at projecting the type of image someone’s looking for, at saying all the right things, and doing all the right things. If anyone has had the experience of meeting the “perfect partner”, only to be dumped by them unceremoniously and left with a soul-crushing heart-wrenching pain as a result, you know firsthand how devastating the disguise is.

The reason I mentioned all this is that one of the warning bells worth listening to when considering a partner’s potential for an affair is how the pain and emptiness YOU feel compares to what they seem to be feeling. The more of an imbalance there is, the more your partner is hiding or shutting off the painful and empty parts of themselves. It doesn’t mean they’ll have an affair, but it kicks up the odds.

While we’re on the subject, there’s also a very close cousin to affairs that surprisingly is more accepted by our society than infidelity. And it’s one of the things a partner is terrified of when wondering whether their partner is having an affair, or is going to have one.

It’s called serial monogamy. It’s practiced in Hollywood constantly. Instead of having a serious outside relationship while still in the initial one, the partner will scout for a new potential partner while the other relationship is deteriorating, while still acting as if they want to stay in the initial relationship. Once the new possible relationship looks promising enough, the partner will stop their pretences, and let the initial relationship deteriorate rapidly. (Usually they tell their horror stories to the new prospect, which cements THEIR closeness even more, and gives them good alibis when the new relationship takes off). In fact, the more unhappy the left-behind partner is, the more likely the leaving partner will have their partner’s “irrational” behavior to use as an excuse for leaving. The main difference between an affair and serial monogamy is that consummation of the new relationship doesn’t take place until the leaving partner has split. It’s a split hair though, but one the leaving partner uses like a banner to show that they have kept their “morals intact”.

Okay, enough for the foreword.:)

Recognizing your own need to attach yourself to a man is a very good step for you. Your need for closeness and his need for distance are mirror images of each other (in a mirror, right is left, remember?). When we are afraid of getting hurt, we tend to keep our distance from someone. His flirting is his subconscious way of bringing up that fear in you. By being loving one moment, and flirting the next, you never know when it’s safe to be vulnerable with him, and the natural way of dealing with this is to be close only when there’s enough of a guarantee of emotional safety. So he gets his fixes of “separateness”, which helps him quiet the panic he feels when you are very close to him emotionally. That doesn’t make it right; but it might help explain why he does what he does.

Choices like this where one partner has to lose for the other to “win” are really lose/lose. We make choices like this because they buy us time, because they’ve worked better than any other solutions we found in the past. What’s the win/win here, the truly loving solution?

Here’s my guesses. First, his struggle with closeness is exactly what YOU need to remind you of the importance of healing your own struggle over separateness (fear of abandonment). Pain is the teacher of last resort. WE feel it when we refuse to listen closely to our inner voice.

Right now your fear of abandonment makes it very hard for you to set clear emotional boundaries of your own. Being able to tell him how you feel about his flirting, and THEN letting him know that you consider it unacceptable, and will do what you need to take care of your well-being - is all part of setting your own boundaries. Your options may be leaving, or telling him to leave, or not sleeping with him, or going to therapy, or a whole host of other options. And you have the right not to tell him what any of your options are, as well as the right to change your mind from moment to moment about which option feels best for you.

If your motive is setting your boundaries is to take care of your well-being, not getting him to change, it will give both of you better chances of finding a win/win solution. He DOESN’T have to change for you to feel better. You may find that this freedom gives him a real chance to think about how his behavior is robbing both of you; the more openly and honestly you can talk to him about YOUR feelings and thoughts, the easier it will be to listen to him when he gives you tiny snippets of what’s happening inside him. He’s looking for a better solution too, but right now he probably has no idea what that solution could be. Remind him you’re interested in win/win, and that you’re committed to carrying your half of any work to find the win/win solutions.

You said “I have never criticized or complained about anything he does or is.”. While on the surface this might seem supportive, it masks your true feelings. When we feel natural anger over something and hide it away, it’s like a volcano, ready to erupt without warning. Inside, he’ll be wary of this repressed anger (which his internal radar can pick up across the room), and his wariness will feed his need to keep some distance. Accept whatever anger you feel, and if you don’t feel safe expressing it with him, find SOMEONE to help you validate it. That’s being honest with him, and yourself.

Finally, a few points. His ex-wife’s “mental illness” tells more than meets the eye. It sends a subliminal message to you that if you act too crazy or irrational, you’ll be painted with the same kind of paintbrush as his ex-wife. If I can’t BE crazy when I need to, than I’d really go nuts. I’d suggest checking your gut feelings on this, and going where it leads you. About your ex-husband: his affairs increase the odds that you are going to be attracted to men with similar struggles, and ways of dealing with those struggles. That said, I have no idea what the odds are. Furthermore, the biggest help your past can give you is helping you see what kinds of old fears and pain FUELLED your ex’s choices, and then finding out what part you played in the dance that was a part of coping with those choices. If you can find ways of stepping back from that dance, it will help you see your current relationship more clearly. The more you compare the POSSIBLE ways your current partner is similar to your ex, the harder it will be to treat him as a unique individual. Seeing your ex wear sneakers will help you recognize when your current partner is wearing sneakers, but that’s different than saying “omigosh, he’s wearing my ex’s sneakers!”

I guess I’ve rambled on long enough for now, eh?:)

From: Kristine

Thank you so much for this answer. It's so full of insight that it's going to take me several days to absorb it all and reply fully. I just wanted to say this before the message scrolls way down the board. In so many ways, this is exactly what my friend has been trying to tell me, except that he can't be so frank--for obvious reasons, maybe. If he told me everything, I guess the "distancing" tactics wouldn't serve his purposes, would they? It means a lot to me to hear it from another person.

From: Contemplator

Kristine, Some of what you wrote hit a note with me today as I have been looking for more info on extra-marital affairs even though I have never HAD one...just contemplating it thoroughly. I haven't got a clue as to why this hit me now, since I never thought about it seriously before, not until a specific married man at work (I've only been there a few months and he started after I did) showed interest in me and I him. Now I'm a healthy wench and I often daydream about others but that's as far as it has ever gotten and I've always felt I had a good attitude about sexuality. I'm very open, giving and adventurous with my older-by-23-years hubby who loves me to pieces and I him.

We have two children together and he's a great Daddy to them and partner/lover/friend to me. There's no question of me NOT wanting to be married to my hubby! Though I've been terribly curious as to what it would be like to have sex with someone in my lifetime OTHER than my spouse. I never had sex until I met my husband, you see. I was very adamant about waiting...not for marriage, but for the one man I felt completely comfortable and unreserved with...that's my hubby! He's always seemed to me, the one person who knows ME best - the good and the bad. For weeks now I've been relishing thoughts of being with this other man...he's very different from my hubby: athletic, fit, likes to go out and do things (not sit at home watching TV every night), he's still older than I by ten years but my husband is another 12 years over that #. I'm very much a "thinker." I have spent countless hours envisioning every possible scenario for how to deal with this if I do. Like where, when, what will I tell him so that he won't think I'm "in love" with him - which I'm not - and that this is truly a separate thing from being married.

I don't WANT to break up my marriage though from what this guy tells me about his current situation, I'm surprised he's been in it so long! If it weren't for his kids, he *wouldn't* be in it still, he says. Admirable yet...I can't believe a healthy 40+ year old male could live year after year with someone he doesn't share a bed, or hardly a life with! Then there's the issue of working together - I'm thinking neither of us wants things to get weirded out later on so one of us feels like we can't work with the other...I want to make sure we BOTH are honest about this up front. And he has been, so far. I know my faults and what I will have to work on if this *does* happen. Hey, I can get jealous sometimes! And I'm a very sensitive soul - quite a daydreamer, yet can be very realistic too. I know myself to be selfish at times...this would be a very selfish act, wouldn't it? Obviously, I hate lying to my hubby and will do everything to protect his feelings.

Yet, is it possible to be honest with him about this now or later and not lose him? He's already been through one divorce due to his first wife of 17 years leaving him for another (he still didn't want to divorce) - and it wasn't for sex, since hubby said she was not too thrilled with being intimate. (I'm the complete opposite of her, he says!) So any thoughts here? Should I just buckle down and keep telling myself to forget it? Or should I go for it? Either way, I'm heading towards miserable it seems. This is the only other time in my life I've felt totally attracted to and completely comfortable with a man...we can talk freely and hey, he likes ME too! That surprised me for some reason...I know I'm pretty and desirable but no where near drop-dead gorgeous with a perfect body. Anyhow, this guy would make a real good friend if I left it at that...but I'd still lust after him! ;)

From: Kristine

Hmmm...This was not the kind of comment I was expecting, and I am not an expert on this, since I was faithful to my husband for our 14 year marriage. And if this were 5 years ago, I would have "virtually" screamed at you in ALL CAPS--NO, DOOON'T! But here is my opinion, anyway. There is a good chance that if you do have this affair, you will be eventually found out. Maybe not, but it's a very real risk, and you have to be ready for this. Also, if you are, and it is, you will probably hurt your husband very much. Are you sure that he really believes (not just says) that his wife didn't leave him because of sex? Sometimes we say things that are the opposite of what we fear in order to cover up that fear. Maybe he is secretly afraid that she wasn't keen on sex with HIM because he is not very good in bed--think this one through. You could be wielding a very powerful weapon here, if it's discovered. Also, from what I've heard, sex in extra-marital situations isn't much different from the married kind. I've been faithful in marriage, but I've now had three partners in my life (that's few, compared to some people, but about average, if some statistics can be believed), and there isn't a whole lot of difference, when you get right down to it--or at least enough difference to risk wrecking your marriage over. (Maybe if you've had ten, you start seeing huge differences, but gee--is it worth it?)

Anyway, I like Bernd's approach to this--you have to think in terms of healthy choices. And if you're itching to do this, probably nothing will eventually stop you--you might resist now and with this guy, but not later. And I no longer believe in trying to coerce people on "moral" grounds alone. There are just too many different situations and circumstances--no one sees that more than I do. But curiosity alone doesn't seem like a strong enough reason to risk setting off this atom bomb you're "contemplating" now. ...Anyway, I'm sure you'll be getting some powerful posts by others, so I'll not add anything more.

From: Contemplator

Kristine, Thanks for the reply! Made me cool off just a tad, but that guy is *still* all I can think about lately. (Very time consuming too! Geez!) I'm pretty realistic about the quality of sex in an extra-marital relationship, in this case in fact, I certainly wouldn't expect it to be better! Even given my relative inexperience, my hubby is damned good in my book. It's the idea of learning all about another person, sharing activities together that I don't and probably *never* WILL with my hubby. "I'm too young to feel so old!" is the thought that keeps running through my mind. For example, I wanna try windsurfing...my hubby hates the water AND thinks it's crazy to want to do something like that. Meanwhile, there are LOTS of other hobbies/activities (which don't require physical exertion of the sporting type) that hubby and I share that I know I *wouldn't* with this other guy.

But this other guy would jump at the chance to go windsurfing, canoeing or rafting with me...he loves that stuff! And I could try all those "fun" things I've always wanted to do before I get too old to do them. Hmmm, maybe I *should* just try to be "friends" eh? Then I would really have to work towards convincing my hubby that that guy and I are "just friends" and that'll be a bit of work. Hubby trusts me now, but I think he'd be jealous if I spent time with other people like that no matter WHAT we were doing. We've been married almost six years and in that time, we have been each other's best friends and constant companions. I've had no friends to go out with or "couple friends" for us to go out with together for dinner or whatever. It's just been extended family members and that's it.

My mom warned me that even though we were a lovey-dovey married couple, we were too close and needed time outside of our marriage to develop as people. Maybe she's right? Also, I stayed home for 4.5 years as a full-time mom/part-time work-at-home freelancer. Staying home with the kids was grand up until the last year when I thought I'd go nuts for several different reasons and we definitely needed a second income. I got the job opportunity of a lifetime and ta-daa....that's where I am now! I love being able to talk to ADULTS once again and have made a couple close friends with my female co-workers. I'm proud to say our small dept is a wonderful bunch of people! Anyhow, I am and will continue to seriously think about what I might do. I'm glad this guy I'm interested in was open and honest enough with me to tell me how *he* felt too and what his current situation and problems were upfront. He was a gentleman about it, even though I pretty much told him I was thinking about him in "that way", he never tried to take advantage of that fact and reassured me I wasn't being "weird" :) (Hey, I sure felt like it.) I guess I'll find out Monday how *I* am really feeling when I see him again...we had our little talk on Friday you see. Wish me luck and yes, I'm still looking for advice & comments from those more experienced than I. Thanks!

From: Susan

Oh boy, this is a tough one. One thing I will say, the higher the number the MORE alike they become !!!! Without being too indiscreet, I will say more than 10 and less than 100 !!!

I cheated on my first husband, of course we were married at 17 & 19. Could have been just "growing up and apart". At the time I was just a selfish little girl and had absolutely no regrets. Now at 44, I look back and think - "he didn't deserve that". So, I have many regrets that I hurt someone who loved me. That is really the hard part - living with your OWN regrets and pain - so THINK about it VERY carefully. Actually, there is nothing wrong with a little lust, you DON'T have to ACT on your feelings !!!

As to men using cheating as a defence - well, maybe. Then again, he might just be a manipulative jerk who uses women for HIS self esteem. Sometimes the chase is the excitement and once the "hunt" is over - BOOM - you aren't any fun any more. It happens a lot, so be careful with yourself and your commitment to him. Maybe just waiting a while longer will tell you how committed he is to a long term relationship - or just the thrill of the chase. If you are not able to talk with him about this - that is indicative of a problem. If he refuses to see how hurt you are by his flirting, etc. that is also a problem.

I personally think that by him telling you, you are "silly" for having ANY feeling, is a strong indication that there is a problem. No one's feeling are "silly", maybe their actions - but NEVER their feelings. I hope for the best for both of you, only you know what is in your heart.

From: Contemplator

Susan, thanks for the reply! Of course, I know I'll hurt my hubby deeply if he ever found out. I'm the type that usually feels guilty about all kinds of things...I can hardly buy a book or something without feeling guilty I spent money on myself if we've got big bills to pay! (Something my hubby has *no* guilt about whatsoever...okay, that's one of our sore points, just to let ya know!) Anyhow, this is why my lusting after this one guy sorta scares me. Right now, I don't feel one iota of guilt and that's just not like me...it's like whatever morals I had just disappeared into never-never land and I feel like having an affair is the most natural thing to do and "why would anyone object?" when intellectually, I know it's definitely NOT! I'm like...WHERE is my conscience! (It usually works overtime.)

Well, it's coming back slowly but my hormones keep getting in the way. I'm hoping this will just cycle itself out and I won't be having adulterous thoughts in the near future but then I'll have a whole 'nother problem... this guy already KNOWS how I feel/felt and I know he feels somewhat similarly. I already told him I don't want to screw up our working relationship *ever* and he agreed. Man, can I be stupid...if we go ahead with it, even if it's just ONE time...it WILL alter things at work no matter what the outcome, won't it? (Let's rename me "Confused") By the way, just to let y'all know...I most definitely would NOT want to marry this guy EVER. I already know what it's like to be in blended family (have a teenage stepkid who lives with mom & stepdad) and deal with an Ex...even a half-way amicable after-divorce situation like my hubby has with his ex is a royal pain for the second wife (me). I *really* don't wanna go through THAT again (they guy's got two young children.) His way of living is so opposite from what I'm used to, I doubt I'd enjoy it. Thanks again!

From: mzet

Here is my perspective from the husband's-whose-wife-is-having-an-affair side: if you choose to have the affair, the pain that he will experience will be greater than if you and the children (if you have any) would die in an accident . You will cause great suffering.

From your description, if you continue the "friendship" with this guy, eventually you WILL fall in love (if you're not there already! I think you may have, reading between the lines) and nothing will stop you. You will progressively continue to rationalize your choices (as you have been doing and as is reflected on your postings).

Some of the reasons why you may be looking for an affair have to do with the nature of your relationship with your husband and with deep wounds that you yourself have that you don't even know about. If you want to avoid being the cause of all that pain (to your husband, your lover and yourself), I would suggest you begin to explore the problems in yourself and in your marriage first. They may be hidden now, but they are there. An affair will disclose them with a lot of blood and ashes behind your path. But may be there are other avenues to achieve this. I don't know because my wife and I never explored other avenues at the time. In retrospect, I can say that there were serious problems in ourselves and in the relationship, despite the fact that we BOTH thought we had the perfect marriage and we BOTH thought we were OK inside.

If you do choose to have the affair, get ready for hell. I think it can be both the best and the worst thing, at the same time, that can happen to a marriage. But the risks are huge. For example, I almost signed the papers for a divorce twice and we are still not out of the hot water, a year after she started the "friendship" and after she fell in love with the "friend" she has told me repeatedly that she does not love me. We have had no intimate contact (sex, kissing, holding hands, etc. for about six months now). It continues to be very painful for both of us. We see no end to the pain.

Be careful, pain hurts. Take care.

From: Bernd (to Contemplator)

This stage in a relationship is VERY common. Both partners have found a middle ground between closeness and separateness that - while not as fulfilling as they’d like - is comfortable enough. The status quo “works”, and there is a relative peace and stability to the relationship.

Except the growing feeling that “something is missing” becomes more inescapable every day. In your husband, his age makes it easier for him to accept those feelings, because to risk “stirring the pot” (talking about his own emptiness) is too much of a risk. He’s been thru the pain of one failed relationship; he doesn’t have the stomach for another one.

In you, the disappointment of “is this all there is?” is stirring away inside of you, and makes you a prime risk for an affair. The longer the status quo in your marriage continues - no matter how good you convince yourself the marriage is - the harder it will become to not act on those feelings. Once you actually have an affair - even if it’s only for one night - that secret will make true closeness between you impossible. The secret becomes like an impregnable wall, and no matter how many windows you put in it to make it make it look less like a wall, it will remain an impregnable barrier - until the truth comes out.

Your FEELINGS are healthy. Feelings give us important clues about how we are still letting ourselves to be short-changed in life. But feelings aren’t choices.

You mention that an affair would be selfish. I’ll go a step further. An affair would not be selfish enough! When we are REALLY selfish, we want the most we can get. The choices that ALWAYS give us back the most are choices that are truly loving ones - win/win/win, etc. In our relationship, we’ve found that when we are the MOST selfish, we find solutions that far exceed what we initially wanted. We get more than we asked for, and it’s ALL nice - no unpleasant after effects, no secrets.

Every need and desire you have, your husband has as well. Every unmet, or unfulfilled desire you have is matched by a similar unfilled desire in your husband. The solutions each of you might be exploring may be a lot different, and how aware you each are of those unmet needs may also vary widely. Each of you is “settling” for less than you deserve and need in certain areas of your lives. Each of you is also the BEST one to help each other find solutions, because of the ways each of your needs fit together like jigsaw pieces.

My suggestion is talk. If you talk well together now, then make a goal of bringing your talking to even higher levels of intimacy. When you can share with him everything you’ve shared with us about what you are thinking and feeling - and both of you feel comfortable and close as you share it and after - then you will have something that is very very powerful and wonderful. There is something magical that happens at each new stage of intimacy, that opens new doors to intimacy and solutions to fulfil important needs we have that we never saw before.

If you are both willing to talk, and explore, and search actively for win/win, there is NOTHING that you can’t have that is part of filling you up inside with love and happiness. Your desire to explore new sexual boundaries can be met more safely, and with more possibilities for mutual fulfilment and happiness, by exploring those desires together with lots of talking first. It won’t always be easy, because the unknown is always scary, until we’ve taken the time to get familiar with it, and find out where the paved areas are, and where the potholes are.

Be selfish. Be very very selfish. Don’t settle for anything less than the solutions that give you the most back - permanently. Don’t settle for anything less than the most loving solution for yourself. The one that is the most loving for you, will be the most loving for your husband as well. That is the route to true happiness.

We’ve been down the other road. It’s got one hell of a painful invisible dropoff. Good luck.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.