archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

I Think I want her back - William

I was in a relationship with a girl for 2 and half years. It was my first relationship and the hardest thing I have every had to go threw. First, it might help to tell you something about myself. I am 24 years old. I was a part time college student and had a full time job when I meet my girlfriend. We meet in a bar and we were together everyryday for our first year. Everything, was magical for the first year. I guess that is to be expected. However, the second year things started to change for the worse. I contribute a lot of the problems to myself. My mother was looking for away for me to pay for college. In her quest we discovered that I had a learning dis. and was diagnosed with add (not adhd). This was a hard time for me not only because it lowered myself esteem but I felt she was looking down on me. I tried to talk to my girlfriend about what was going on and ask her to bare with me. Things only got worse we fought over the dumbest things. I never really yelled at her or lost control, but I advoided her. We both spent more time with our friends and to make things worse I moved back home because of my job.

The distance between were we worked and school made it hard for the both of us to see each other as before. I was really struggling with a calculus class, and spending even less time with her. However, I did try to sit down with her on several occasions and explain this would all pass. We discussed marriage (i made it clear only after i graduated) and thought we were doing ok. Then one night I went to a local bar and found her dancing with someone else. To make a long story short she dumbed me for that guy. Turns out he was a gynecologist (that was another big blow to myself esteem). It has been three of the worst months of my life. We keep running into each other everywhere we go. Her new boyfriend took a job out of town. About a month ago she called and we went out. She told me that she missed me and started to cry. I know she still loves me ( i can see it in her eyes).

Before you make any judgements I must tell you I was no saint to her. However, I did make it a point to express my feelings to her on several occasions (positive feelings). Meanwhile, we are about to start school and we will see each other everyday. I finally got money to go school because of my disability (quit my job). I have learned a lot about myself and what I want out of life threw this experence. I can honestly say there has been several positive things to come out of this break up (call it growing up or whatever). Now, I am not sure were to go from here. I think she is having problems with whats his name and I think I want her back. Well, I know I want her back! Sure I should keep in mind that number one she dumped me, number two if we got back together could we work things out, and number three, most important, she is still with him. Confused! Confused! Confused!

From: Bernd

I can identify with you a bit re: your A.D.D. I have struggled with biologically-based chronic depression all my life, which made university a real struggle (even tho I had graduated with honours from high school). I dropped out, and have had a succession of low-paying jobs, and periods of unemployment for the last 25 years. My self-esteem took a helluva beating too.

Here are some thoughts that came to me while reading your posting. We are all looking for security (i.e. safety) in love - especially emotional. For many, financial security plays a significant part of this. So all else being equal, a gynaecologist is going to have more hearts jumping than a ditch digger. The more a woman wants or needs financial security from her partner, the scarier it is when the possibility looms that her man is going to have job and career problems.

But like in the song "Lying Eyes" by the Eagles, sometimes we pay a huge price for "financial security", like minimizing other things that may be lacking in a relationship, especially emotional things. It sounds like your girlfriend went to "where the grass is greener", and found that she still wasn't as happy as she thought she'd be. That's scary for her.

When we have problems in one relationship, 50% of those problems are almost always our responsibility. We deal with struggles, our inner pain, and other childhood issues the best way we can, and whatever we haven't healed continues to cause us problems in any new relationship. My guess is that she'll continue having difficulties no matter if she stays with him, or comes back to you.

My hunch is if she comes back in your life, you'll continue to be afraid that the same thing will happen again. And the natural thing is to try to do whatever you can to give her what you think she wants, as far as reassurance, attention, and proving yourself in college.

I say that's the natural thing. But it usually doesn't work. My suggestion is to begin looking at how you use relationships - and this girl - to help you boost your self-esteem, to help you feel loveable. Begin to search for things that will help you feel better about yourself, regardless of what direction this relationship goes. When 2 people depend on each other for feelings of self-worth and inner safety, it's often like 2 people with sprained ankles trying to walk together - they just end up stumbling and tripping over each other, and eventually hurting each other.

Give this girl the freedom to be with you, or not. The less manipulated she feels, the safer she'll feel with you, and that gives you the best chance for a caring relationship with her, whether it ends up being just friends, or lovers.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.