archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

The awful pain of adultery - Sadder than sad

I am a Christian dedicated to chastity before marriage. My friend was celibate less for religious reasons than for AIDS-scare reasons, but he agreed to celibacy while he was with me, out of respect for my faith. We are both in our 40's, mature, ready for companionship, but neither of us has ever married.

We got to be very close over the last 18 months and saw each other virtually every day. I saw him through legal messes and serious illness. Mostly, he just was my confidant and friend.

I felt very committed to him, almost married. My needs were for trust and companionship and he met those needs. I told him I was in love with him.

He didn't feel the same way, but he never made it really clear to me. He always told me I was very special to him, Number 1, he didn't ever want to lose me or disappoint me.

BUT... Over my birthday and Christmas he had a brief affair with a "fatal attraction"-type woman he met in my church singles' group. She told him at the outset that she had a sexual addiction, loved to destroy relationships, boasted of numerous affairs on previous husbands, and had no desire other than to "get in his pants". He went for it. He had unprotected sex with a highly promiscuous woman. And all along, he was angry with himself because he knew it would kill me and kill 'us'.

I feel just devastated. For some reason, he thinks we can continue our friendship, even at a diminished level, because I'm a "10" and I'm so forgiving and he needs me.

I just can't do it. I was in love with him. I see that he had no concern for me at all, because this isn't how you treat a "10".

Why in the world would a man choose a soulless prostitute over someone like me?

And why can't he even remember the 18 months that we had? He has forgotten it all...

... which is what pains me the most.

Can you tell me anything that will ease this horrible burden?

After months of struggling, I finally told him I just couldn't see him any more. It is just too hard. I am beginning to see him as a heartless man with no capacity to really love.

From: Bernd

One of the questions you’re likely asking yourself is why God didn’t guide you towards more happiness in choosing a partner, instead of the excruciating hurt you’re dealing with right now. There’s a quote that comes to mind: “sometimes we cry out to God when our foundations are shaking, only to find out it’s God doing the shaking”.

A personal relationship with God provides us with a capacity for great love, and discovery of new miracles. However, it also brings us squarely to some very difficult crossroads, in which we either seek to understand the true directions and lessons God is trying to teach us, or we take the path of following misconceptions from what others have TAUGHT us about God - misconceptions that lead us INTO the swamp, instead of closer to heaven.

Jesus was foremost a rebel, and if you feel you have a personal close relationship with Jesus, then to follow him often means making some very difficult decisions about current “Christian” beliefs.

There are few things that stir up a bigger hornet’s nest than the subject of sexuality. I personally don’t believe - although I certainly used to - that God gave us something so wonderful on the one hand, and then put so many chains on it on the other hand. What Lynda and I have found is that sex is a HUGE playground, and there are so many “safe” areas in that playground which allow us to experience wonderful intimacy with a partner even if we choose not to have intercourse.

There is a fear among many Christians that once you start on the slippery road of sex, that our hormones and sinful nature make it probable that it will lead to intercourse. I don’t buy that. Cage up a person, and they’ll want to break free even more. Give a person a huge playground to play in though, and if they have enough fun in the sandbox, it won’t matter if the swings are off-limits for a while.

There are many ways of having sexual intimacy with a partner without intercourse; and the more comfortable you feel with your sexuality, the easier is becomes to hold true to choices about your own boundaries. Much of the “sex” that Lynda and I have no longer involves intercourse. Examples include nude body massages, playful full-clothed romping and touching, verbal fantasies (I talk to her about making love to her on the deck of a yacht, for example). At one time our sex life was a real struggle. Although we still have a lot of healing to do sexually, things have changed a lot since we started exploring the rest of the “playground”. Now I can set off shivers and even silent orgasms in Lynda just by soft touches, or sensual whispers. Now THAT’S safe sex!

Celibacy is a safe way of staying out of one of the big relationship swamps. However, most people interpret celibacy with locking ourselves (and our sexuality) inside a cage. We miss the beach, the gardens, and so many other beautiful places in shutting ourselves away, because of our fear of the “swamp”.

Ok, enough about my thought about sexuality. It is my guess that there are some unhealthy aspects of your “Christianity” causing you anguish (the unhealthy parts come from hand-me-down beliefs, instead of what Christ may have really been trying to teach). If God is “shaking your foundations” a bit, then you’ll have to make some very difficult choices about rejecting some cherished “beliefs”, and painstakingly searching for the truths God is trying to whisper to you.

One of those areas involves your need to see yourself as a “10”, and the other woman as a “soulless prostitute”. There is an example in the Bible where a prostitute was being judged and condemned by several so-called “righteous” people of the day, and Jesus was the only one who showed kind compassion to her. I suspect that, in your partner’s desperation to ease your hurt over his “affair” with her, that he painted her in a very unfavorable light - which you NEEDED to hear to try to salvage some sense of self-worth yourself. If the other woman is sexually promiscuous, then it’s very likely desperation and fear are parts of what’s driving that. That’s not happiness. Jesus talked about the “poor in spirit” as being very special.

If you really want to follow Jesus example here, talk to that woman - not to try to change or convert her, but to learn from her. Let her help you learn the power of true acceptance; you may find that the things she is most afraid of are the very things that terrify you the most. You both just have different ways of coping. God didn’t bring her into the picture by accident. It may seem excruciatingly difficult to even think of getting to know her, but that’s where the struggle between what God is whispering and what others have taught you really comes out in the wash. Follow the whispers inside.

Now, your partner. He has not changed, but your image of him, and he image he projected has. You asked him to follow YOUR values, and felt love when he did. I suggest that love doesn’t work that way, and that his “change” was a natural consequence of this “bargain”. Love means acceptance, including acceptance of another person’s value system. Your choice to be celibate is healthy, as long as it feels right for you. Your need to have him remain celibate until you marry isn’t healthy, in my opinion. If celibacy is part of his true value system, then he’ll stay celibate because it means a lot to HIM. I suspect however that it isn’t part of his true value system, and hasn’t been. I suspect that it’s an ongoing struggle inside him.

Unless you’re prepared to let him choose his own value system, especially sexually, without any pressure from you, then my guess is that this source of struggle between both of you would continue and increase with time. If you married, you would still need to have a certain amount of control over his sexual choices in order to keep feeling safe. Let me throw out a few triggers: him looking at erotic pictures, wanting to fantasize about having other partners, wanting to try unconventional things (such as bondage, spreading whipped cream over you, etc.). Any of these trigger a gut reaction?

Chances are that some of these set off panic inside you. Sex has been a big source of panic inside me most of my life too, and certainly for Lynda as well. What I’ve found is that, as long as I need Lynda to “be safe” for me, to make choices that don’t set off that panic, I’m putting her in a position that I really need to let God be in. When I let my choices be guide by fear, I’m not letting them be guided by love. That’s why my recovery, my healing have been so important. The only way I can get better at hearing God’s guiding whispers is to clear out more of the old garbage and fears inside that keep blocking those whispers. It’s terrifying at times doing so, because a lot of that garbage forms the walls that seems to have kept me safe over the years. To hand it over to God piece by piece, and let go of that “protection” keeps being among the most difficult things I’ve ever done. But I gotta do it, and keep having faith that - as those walls disappear, God isn’t going to leave me high and dry. And by the way, he certainly HASN’T left me hi and dry.:)

God brought you to this place on your path for a reason. If you really want to transform all the pain and sorrow you’re feeling right now into joy, then search for as long and as hard as it takes to find out why, and what he’s trying to help you discover and heal. Reach out and ask others to help you. Don’t stop until the answers you find feel warm and solid inside; that’s God whispering, and giving you a happy noogie.:)

Hope some of this helps.

From: Sad

It's amazing how fast recovery moves along once you open the door to it.

Your comments were very inspiring and provocative. Perhaps not by coincidence, they parallel some things I've been learning and considering on my own.

There are boundaries that I cannot cross, but there is much that is sensual and fun and loving that I can (and gladly) do -- I told my friend I can't do XYZ, but I can do ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOP... He was afraid if HE got started, he would cross my boundaries, and that's why our friendship remained so platonic. I need to help him with that.

When we broke up, I showed him some of the ABC's, and it was most passionate. Now, with a little healing between us, we've opened up a dialogue... and maybe more will come. I understand things a lot better now and so does he.

As for God, He is infinitely wise and compassionate. There are things I need to learn and relearn and unlearn about Him. Much of my anger and frustration throughout all of this has had to do with what I expected Him to do -- you were absolutely right on that.

As for HER... I knew when I posted the words "soulless prostitute" that something ugly inside of me was finding expression. And yes, my friend painted her viciously and I helped him. It's time to give her a break. I can't talk to her or befriend her, yet. Breaking up homes is something she admits that she does. I don't want to get too close. But in time... In the meantime, I hope it suffices that I haven't made life difficult for her. She doesn't even know that I know.

You have been a tremendous source of wisdom and comfort. God bless.

From: Bernd

It’s neat how seeing circumstances as a blessing, rather than a curse, help to ease the suffering, isn’t it?:)

It sounds like you and God have had a very good quiet and loving talk.

Regarding your partner’s problem with boundaries, my guess is the only way you can really help him with that is to practice remaining true to your own. No matter what another human being wants from us, when we can respect our own boundaries with a solid, warm feeling inside, and stop “trying to care care of THEIR feelings”, things just work out well. In fact, trying to help him with his struggle is like tying one shoelace for a child when they are ready and capable of learning on their own - even when that learning process might be frustrating and scary. We gain confidence in ourselves by doing, and “doing” involves making mistakes and tripping as a natural part of the learning experience.

A final note: because love is acceptance, being okay with someone being angry at you is a very powerful form of love. My guess is that it’s more than okay with God when we are angry at him. I have called him every name under the book, and God has encouraged me to rage at him, to help me learn how anger can really HELP me, not hurt me. Be okay with any anger you feel toward God; it will transform itself on its own. Picture inside your quiet place inside how he feels about you getting peeved at him; do you see him getting angry, or do you see his warm eyes and compassionate face saying “it’s more than okay”. Let the answer you get be your guide.:)

From: C Hoover

There is no greater blow to your self-esteem than to discover that someone you love has betrayed you in this way. I am so sorry.

I can see a lot of that struggle in your letter. You make special mention that this happened during the holiday season and on your birthday. I would guess that he had to tell you you were "number 1" and a "10" and etc. because it was very clear, through your words or your actions, that you felt very uncared for and insignificant to him. "Soulless prostitute" is telling. Were those your words or his? In any case, I think there is just a lot of pain in the damage that was done to your self-esteem and that is more an "intensity of pain" expression than anything else. If he said it, it is probably to help him keep from sinking into the reality of what he did. But that's another topic...

You probably wonder if you mean anything to the Lord, since He didn't protect you from this mess. Rest assured, He is very mindful of your pain. I remember a passage from my body of scripture (I am Mormon) that says God looked over his creation, prior to Noah's day, and wept. When the prophet Enoch asked him why, the Lord replied: Because I created this world and these are my children. I gave them agency and commanded them to love one another. And this is what they do with their agency, hate and hurt one another. Why shouldn't the God of heaven and earth weep? All of my creations weep for the suffering of my people. (Moses 7)

Somehow, it seems to help to know that God is at least aware of your suffering and is weeping right along with you. Remember, He wept at the pain of Lazarus' sisters, too, even knowing that in a few moments, he was going to raise Lazarus from the dead. He grieves with us in the moment that we grieve, even knowing that He is going to bring healing in just a little while.

There are reasons why these things happen and they don't have to do with the quality of person you are... Nor do they have to do with the quality of person he is.

But this isn't the time to deal with that. You're hurting, and I'm glad you are speaking of your hurt. I hope you will find some comfort.

Best wishes.

From: Tess who is not-so-sad-anymore

I've read and re-read your remarks to me and to Remorseful. These exchanges are priceless, did you know that? The diamonds that you offer us glitter like hidden diamonds amid the darkness of our own pain. "Be patient with ourselves, be patient with our sweethearts, allow God to heal your, quit trying to heal others while you are so wounded yourself, allow yourself to make mistakes as you try to reconcile..." It's scathingly brilliant!

I felt a burst of energy, and in one fell swoop I created a "Dealing with Adultery" website. I included links to your ODAT pages as a general resource.

If you ever have a mind to share some of your wit and wisdom, I'm sure we would all benefit. Just to have snippets of your ongoing conversations, for example, with the few outstanding lines, but to have them all in one place, would be so helpful. I would be glad to do it, if you'd like.

My website is at http://members.aol.com/itstessie/sngl/adult.htm if you want to take a look at it.

(I've hosted a website for single adults for two years ... this infidelity thing is a new venture, for me. I'd welcome any suggestions.)

From: Bernd

Great site Tess. The phrase "the Lord moves in mysterious ways" ring a bell here???:)

I've added it to my list of Relationship links. What you are doing is wonderful.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.