archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Trust - Daisy

Trust is one of the biggest issues that I struggle with in my relationship. I have been in my current relationship for almost 4 years. We have been engaged for most of that time...I've been stalling. I have finally agreed to marry him this summer despite some difficulties we still have. Short background on each of us...I was married for 5 years--emotional, sexual abuse and physical threats--I left after beginning an affair with another man; I felt that if I could have feelings for another that my marriage was probably over-after examination I decided it was and left. My mate has been engaged before--broke it off because he didn't really love her. He is also a sexual abuse survivor; abused by a female babysitter for several years as a child but "enjoyed it"--worked on it in therapy for 1 year (we started dating at the tail end of the therapy) and seemed to be doing ok.

Enough of the biography stuff. Our relationship, initially, was excellent: excellent communication, intimacy, friendship...even our friends commented that we redefined the limerance/honeymoon phase. About 8 months after we were dating, for job purposes, we moved to a new state together and our relationship came to a screeching halt. We each did some things to create distrust (i.e. having phone contact with former lovers) and as a consequence bred a severe level of mistrust. Intimacy plummeted...sex, loving gestures, etc. And for the past 3 years we've functionally been roommates as far as I am concerned. I am very affectionate while he is more distant. Things seem to improve but are never great. Some of these problems I attribute to his sexual abuse...he exhibits all of the signs and he was 1000 times better when he was in therapy. He refuses to re-enter therapy because of our professions and location (we are Psychologists in a small town...and no, just because you "have all the information" doesn't mean you can solve your own problems). How can we get past this and begin to feel closer again? We are actively talking about it again because of a recent event...he went out of town with friends and I was worried that he would cheat...I brought it up with him upon his return so we are rehashing all of this stuff again. This time I would like to get somewhere with our conversations....HELP!!!!

From: Bernd

One of the things your situation reminds me of was a question someone asked me when I was taking karate lessons in university: “what’s the most dangerous karate belt level? White, because a white belt knows enough karate to get himself into trouble, but not out of it.”

Your sentence about having “all the information” really struck a chord with me, because I threw the sheer force of my brain power at most of my earlier attempts at recovery, and it worked about as good as using a power saw to pound a nail.

Your backgrounds in psychology are both blessings and liabilities. It gives you both an awareness of the past issues you’re still struggling with, and you can see those issues in lights that few other people can. The liability is that most psychological instruction still is very much “head” work, while real healing - in my experience - only comes about when we tap our spiritual, or intuitive parts of our beings, and surrender to truths that just whiz by our “logical” brain.

It doesn’t matter what your spiritual “beliefs” are, or whether you have any. In my view, there is simply a part of us that works beyond our consciousness in very powerful ways. Looking at it rationally (I’m going to do a little head work for just a bit), when we look at what medical and psychological beliefs were 500 years ago, we can see that a lot of what they “knew” then was primitive, and far outcompassed by what they DIDN’T know, in comparison to the present. I suspect that science is lagging just as much today in dealing with the spiritual aspect of healing, and dealing with past abuse, and relationship struggles. The spiritual sides of our beings may be truly spiritual, or they may be a physical facet of us that we have only started to explore scientifically.

But what we DO know is that those that tap into the “spiritual” part of themselves tap into a very powerful healing mechanism. AA, and all the other 12 step groups show plenty of evidence of that. Mine and Lynda’s lives certainly do.

Our “inner voice” knows fundamental basic truths about love and life that our brains miss the boat on completely. And considering the phrase “garbage in, garbage out”, if part of our “knowledge” comes from examples of dysfunctional behavior around us, and in our childhood (where the imprints run deep and firm), it’s logical that we’d keep tumbling into the relationship potholes, if what we’ve learned is from other people in our past that fell in the very same types of holes.

One of the most difficult things for me to do is “unlearn”, not learn. I graduated at the top of my class from high school, so for most of my adult life I’ve been using my brain for every problem I could in our marriage, and in my own floundering with confusing emotions and past pain. I did, that is, until Lynda’s affair blew THAT way of handling things outta the water. It’s a good thing it happened when it did, cause I shudder to think (ooops) how much longer I would have stayed on that dead end road if that insanity in my life hadn’t happened when it did.

I had to “unlearn” to stop applying what I “knew” to my struggles, and empty my mind, and cease my efforts to try and think out solutions. Ironic, ain’t it? But when I find the quiet inside, and the calmness (my spiritual side), my intuition, my emotions, and my head somehow all start working in harmony, instead of discord. The answers just COME, without effort. And sometimes they are so simple, so easy, it reminds me of the line “can’t see the forest for the trees”.

It doesn’t surprise me that your boyfriend doesn’t want to return to therapy. In AA and Al-anon, there are many who (unfortunately) begin the process of recovery only to discontinue it when it’s eased their immediate turmoil enough to be bearable, or manageable. True recovery only happens when we accept that we have a disease that is not of our own making, or choosing, but is one that will continue to make our lives more unmanageable if we don’t treat it appropriately. An unwillingness to surrender, to accept our inability to manage emotional and spiritual unwellness inside of us by willpower alone, is very much part of most of our struggles with past abuse, alcoholism, and other emotional and spiritual trauma. Like coughing when we have a cold, it’s very much part of the disease.

The abrupt change in your relationship after you moved away also makes sense. With abuse in both of your pasts, each of you has a level of closeness that inside terrifies the hell out of you. When that invisible line is crossed, a flood of emotions (including panic) is released, and one of the surest and quickest ways of escaping that turmoil - and putting the brakes on the closeness - is thru an outside affair. Our brain is pretty good at explaining emotions at times, but pretty lousy at plugging the holes in the dike when the flood starts.

You didn’t make any mention of any therapy or recovery process that you’re currently involved in to continue healing from your past abuse. Such work, in my opinion, is essential if you want to find some healthy ways of dealing with your current relationship struggles. If you aren’t currently in therapy yourself, your boyfriend may very well be thinking “she doesn’t, why should I?” He may be looking for YOU to “fix” your problems, in much the same way you’re looking for him to make some changes. The more each of you is focusing on the other’s recovery, the less attention you have available to focus on your own, and the dance will continue, and very likely get worse.

From my experience, nothing you attempt will lead him back to therapy, except maybe temporarily. It was only when I let go of trying to get Lynda into therapy, that she eventually found her own way there - when she was ready, and because she WANTED to. When you give your partner complete freedom to choose recovery or not to choose, the past pain they are carrying has a way of coming to the surface and grabbing their attention like never before. Al-anon calls it “detachment”. It works, even if it takes time to develop.

If you are involved in a sexual abuse survivors’ support group right now, then my sense is that group will help you find the answers that already lie inside you. If there isn’t a group, I’d suggest starting one - and being part of it as an equal peer, not a therapist. A therapist role would very likely keep you in “head” mode, instead of supporting a healing process that brought your head, emotions, and spirituality more in harmony.

There’s a saying in Al-Anon that “insanity is when we do things the same way over and over again, and expect different results”. We’re all entitled to have some insanity in our lives, but it’s also nice to more of the alternative as we get older. The psychology hasn’t brought you to the solutions you are looking for; maybe it’s time to start looking at what CAN work.

Hope this helps a bit.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.