archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Does he really love me - Cin

I have had a long history of heartache. When I was 19, I got married for the wrong reasons. Had an ongoing affair with a man I date now. My marriage lasted 11 years and I can honestly say I left the marriage because of our problems not because someone else would be waiting for me. Guess what after 1 year of being out on my own I started dated this man I had an affair . We have known each other for about 10 years. I love this man but can't seem to undersand why he loves me when things are going good. But then when we argue he wants to quit the relationship. Am I just fooling myself. Is he confused or really doesn't know what he wants. I'm torned between telling him its over and starting again, or do I take the chance and give him time to get his feeling together. He has left me before but has always come back. I am not an insecure person. I work full time, take care of 2 childred, and go to school 2 nights a week. PLEASE I NEED TO KNOW WHAT TO DO. DO I SAY GOODBY AND MAYBE HE WILL COME TO REALIZE HE TRULY LOVES ME OR LET HIM GO AND SAVE MYSELF THE HURT OF HIM COMING TO ME LATER ON TO SAY" I DON'T KNOW WHAT I WANT, I NEED SOME TIME". PLEASE I REALLY NEED SOME ADVICE.

From: Bernd

It’s okay to be insecure. In fact, it’s very human. For both of you. I think fear is very much at the root of both of your roller coaster rides. Fear that when you let down your walls, the other will hurt you (and this usually happens for real, which reinforces it). Fear that “it’s my fault”. A deep down subconscious fear that we’re really not worthy of being loved. And a big one - a fear that we’ll never find out whatever seems to be driving us off the deep end of the pain cliff at times when we least expect it.

My guess is that inside there’s some real anger at the load you’re carrying in this relationship - working, housework, kids, and school. It wears me out just thinking about it. That anger (and I suspect there’s more from your past buried under it) needs to be accepted, and felt fully, in a safe place at first, which means NOT with your partner. That anger is okay; it’s trying to tell you something very important that can help you, but it can’t do that until you let yourself really feel it, and accept it. You may think that pushing it down is less riskier than accepting it fully, but it’s leaking out when you least expect it anyway, and in other ways that likely often get beyond any real control. In reality, we can’t lock away ANY of our emotions; if we don’t accept them by free choice, they come out another way, and that way usually ends up causing us even more pain. This may be a bit of a gross example, but I think it cuts right to the point. If you don’t go to the bathroom for the next week, what’s likely to happen to your body and your life? It would go very much right down the tubes. As much as we dislike the products of such bodily functions, “letting them out fully” is essential to our physical health. When we don’t choose where to “let out crap”, it has a way of coming out in ways and at times that cause us BIG problems. (Enough of the gross comparisons!:)

Can you tell me a bit more about your childhood; whether there was any abuse you can remember, and what things caused you real pain as a child? Those imprints run deep; in my experience, cutting off weeds at the surface just lets them grow back again, sometimes even stronger. It’s only when I go to the roots of my own weeds that I’m able to find a way to release them forever.

Hope to hear more from you. Hope this gives you a little start, and a little hope.

From: cin

Hi Bernd. I'm one of six children and my mother raised us alone. She became verbally abusive when I was about ten. I constantly ran away from home and was a very lost teenager. I saw alot in life to early and became very mature at a young age. My half brother sexually abused me when I was 5 and 6. I forgive him now because it came out and he suffers from retardation. He has a mind of a 15 year old. I don't have any sexual hangups and I'm a very open person. I wasn't when I was married but I am now. My present relationship is what I struggle with everyday. At first I didn't think I wanted anything committed but now I want a little more. My children adore this man and I love him dearly. I love him for what he. He has low self esteem because he only made it to grade 9 or 10 and is not a very good reader or writer. This doesn't bother me at all. Things like this make me believe I truly love him. Sometimes when we talk he seems like he wants a more commited relationship. Like talking about buying a house or doing thing with my children. Family things. Then other times he seems like he doesn't know what he wants. Am I expecting to much to soon. Or is he truly afraid. I'm the only person that has never left him. His past relationships have been 2 to 6 months and the women always leave.

From: Bernd

Cin, Your posting about your past really shed a lot of light on your current struggle. Thank you for your openness - I know there are others here who will be able to identify with some of the very painful things you had to face as a child.

It is a very natural and loving part of us that wants to forgive painful trama that we experienced as a child. But forgiveness work takes time, and it also takes mending the deep wounds we’ve gotten inside that are often buried beyond our awareness. The irony about the struggles many of us have in our current relationships is that they are often very direct signposts to healing that we THOUGHT we did, but still very much need to do. You’ve given that process a good start; now it’s time to look at what else needs to be done.

I suspect that one of the things you still feel inner rage over is how the adults of the world - including your mom and absent dad - allowed all that childhood shit to happen. Part of the old anger I’m still dealing with revolves around “Where they hell were they????!”, when I think of all the adults (including my parents) that left children out to dry in varying degrees. When you said you had become “very mature” as a child, the reality is more likely you had to assume an adult role which would have SHUT DOWN your natural process of maturation. You lost a childhood, and until you get it back - replace it with something better - you’ll keep trying to compensate for that loss in frustrating ways.

If you’ve lost hope that you’ll ever be able to get back your childhood, the next best thing - on an unconscious level - is to help someone else. This is very human, and very natural. Your choice of a partner who has a lot in common with your brother doesn’t feel like a coincidence to me. They are both people that “no one else wants” - or few other people want. You know that feeling of being alone, of being unwanted intimately, and your heart goes out to others who have similar struggles.

My guess is that you are also caught between two very opposing needs: one, to love and accept someone that needs it as much as your husband does, and two - to have enough of your turn to be “taken care of”, instead of you doing all or most of the “taking care”. With your husband’s past and difficulty with education, I suspect that he often feels like a failure in taking care of you, which would lead to anger and resentment.

Do you have treasure here, or a swamp? My guess is both, and neither. This relationship holds some tremendous lessons about love and healing, but they will not come easy should you decide to search for them. If you do, here’s what I see as essential ingredients.

- A search back into the still-present after effects of your childhood abuse. You may find this thru therapy, but I think an appropriate support group would likely be the best source of discovery and healing. Hearing others talk and cry over their past abuse, and talking to them, will likely trigger open the hidden trapdoors you still need to find. I suspect that logically you feel you’ve “done this route”. My suggestion is just go with it for a while, and see what unfolds, without expectations either way.

- A rebuilding of your childhood. Impossible? Not at all. One of the things about being the “responsible” one is that it shuts off many of your opportunities to be a child, to nurture that child within. You don’t have to give up your work, or shelve any of your other important responsibilities to let your inner child out to play. What it takes is a commitment to treating your inner child with the same love, kindness and caring as you want to treat your own children. Taking the chance to turn a moment of work into play, for example. Any reason why you can’t do a jig in the middle of making supper? Feel foolish? That’s the true indicator it’s your child you’re letting dance!:) Every moment and memory you give yourself that has a childlike quality to it will build new childhood memories inside of you - REAL memories. That is powerful healing stuff. And it will enhance your ADULT life in immeasurable ways. Ask Lynda.

- A new honesty about your relationship with your husband. As much as you want to “help” him with his difficulties - and unless I’m reading wrong, somewhere between the lines I’m picking up this includes sex - the only truly loving way you can help him is by healing yourself. In doing this, you’ll be able to make more loving choices that are win/win for both of you, without him feeling as if you are the “smart, able one”, and him the lucky recipient of your love. When one partner feels less equal than the other - even if there seem to be “rational” reasons for this imbalance - resentment and strife become natural byproducts. God gives us each our own unique gifts; many of those aren’t valued by society, but we each have the opportunity of finding their real value in our relationships and lives. As you’ve already discovered, he’s great with the kids. There are plenty of geniuses who are atrocious with kids. Try to begin looking for how you two fit together like puzzle pieces, each one complementing the other with a strength where the other has a weakness. Aim for equality, try to wait more for an “invitation to help” before “helping him” with something, and look for ways to build mutual respect.

I’m going to shut off my motor mouth now.:) Hope some of this helps you in some small way. You have touched me with your caring, compassion, and desire to make a difference. Thanks.

Big huggggs


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.