archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Are material gifts important? - Gift giving dilemma

I have been in a 2 year relationship (I think...I haven't been counting) with a girl. Initially, she had another boyfriend. She has been back with him a few times when he comes into town. She sees his sister often (they are friends). The jealously can be hard to deal with I suppose.

Sometimes it is hard to understand why she hangs onto either relationship. It seems we have a very nice relationship in that we both seem to truly care and love each other, or at least are very accepting of each other and wish each other well in our endeavours, are concerned with each other's endeavours, and other trials and tribulations of life.

We just kinda get along. We have our disagreements such as decorating styles, but they are never disputes. We have an exciting love. Our lovemaking was extremely exciting at first, now we sorta just have a routine. I think now it is just a mutual trade of orgasms almost. We have a pleasant feeling when we are around each other and other generally very happy around each other, have fun, etc....

For her birthday I did a picnic, roses, irises, and weird cards with a personalised love message. I just find it hard for me to give any kind of material gifts. I want to give jewellery and other such gifts as nice clothes. But it just seems I cannot bring myself to getting a nice material gift. I've probably spent alot of money last Christmas buying several small gifts instead of on big gift. I've given plants, vibrators, pornos, taken her shopping, roses, etc... Lots of stupid gifts, if you can call it that.

I am usually very gift giving and purchase very nice gifts, including huge gifts for my mother and my nephew. I love giving gifts. Why can't I seem to purchase a real gift for her? Does this mean that I do not love her? Yeah, we occasionally joke about not loving each other, though sometimes I think we mean it and it is not from that emotional feel of "I Love You".

I guess right now I have a couple of good gift ideas. I know the jewellery style she likes very well. And even wish I could purchase it. I am however in a situation right now where I am starting my own business and am just now starting to receive the kind of contracts that I can make a living doing. I also returned to school to finish a degree doing this time so I am quickly going into debt. If it wasn't for the job situation, do you think I would give a gift?

And if so, what would this mean?

From: Bernd

My gut feeling is that something inside you is tugging at your shirtsleeves, and telling you that expressing love thru gifts isn't the most rewarding or the best way of saying "I love you". A difficulty with gifts too is that there's almost an unwritten rule that you have to make each new gift more meaningful, or better than the last. We are disappointed inside when a gift we give doesn't give our partner waves of emotion or happiness. We look for those hidden signs of disappointment - does she really like it? Did I screw up and disappoint her? Sometimes we end up feeling like shit inside, because we feel we've let her down.

If someone has grown up with gifts as a big part of their parents way of saying "I love you", that's what they're used to. It's not unlike growing up in a home where food is the main "I love you" sign - someone with that background will be a lot more likely to use food as an adult to get back some feelings of being loved.

The kind of gifts that never become boring, or too expensive, are those that come from the heart, not the wallet. Sometimes it takes a painful transition period to "unlearn" the old kind of gift giving, and substitute something better. Letting go of something that has grown as familiar as an old coat is never easy, but if that coat is dragging you down, keeping it doesn't make happiness any easier to find.

Try little touches. The kind of things that kids love doing is a great place to start. A treasure hunt that ends with 100 kisses all over her body, with playful teasing and giggling. Body marking, where she gets to paint and colour you up (maybe paint-by-number??) from head to toe, then take a picture of you! Surprise little notes, telling her "why I love you". When you look at how children play, you discover that they can have fun with the simplest of things, and their imagination is their greatest "gift". Give her yours - it has a limitless supply; it invigorates you when you "spend" it, instead of depleting you; and when combined with other gifts that you spend money on, it transforms them from a material thing to something that has a magical little memory attached to it. If you give her jewellery that is the prize from a treasure hunt where the clues are a trail of fun, romantic love notes, every time she wears that jewellery she'll be reminded of the excitement and the special romantic magic she felt that day. That jewellery will become priceless in it's own way, and the biggest glittering diamond won't make her feel as warm and loved inside as those memories.

Finally, don't expect her to "love" everything you try. All you can do is give it your best shot each time, and learn from practice. It will take her time to build faith that she is loveable and very desired even when she isn't getting the "kind of gifts" she's been used to. She may feel very unloved at times. During such times, remind her that you want to give her something that no one else has, or will ever have - you, from the heart. Remind her you're learning how to do that, and listen to her fears, wishes, hopes and hurt, to get better insight into what she REALLY wants most deep inside. We all want to feel loved, and cherished. A lot of us just have a bunch of difficulty trying to find out how to get those in ways that really make us glow inside.

Hope this helps a bit.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.