archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Loving two men in two different ways - alone

I have written a few things on this forum hoping for answers but not being completely honest. It wasn't until after reading most of the letters, I decided to be completely honest with myself and others on this forum to get the most honest replys that I can. I'm 32 years old. I got married at 19 to a man I met at 15. He was 25 when we got married. My mother raised 6 kids on her own. My mother drank alot when I was 10years old till about 15. I moved out when I became serious with my now almost ex-husband (WELL WERE ONLY SEPERATED, BUT FOR 3 YRS ON AND OFF). After we got married he became a different person. I use to love to cook for him, make his lunches, just try to make him happy. He would come home and just lie on the couch and it always seemed like he had something on his mind or that he was mad at me. I used to ask him what was wrong, he would say nothing.

After six months, I started thinking "this is not what I want" so I moved out to live with my sister. I dated but I missed my husband. So we got back together and moved out of his parents house. At 21 I had my daughter, we were seperated when I found out I was pregnant, so we got back together. Things were good for a while, I worked, he worked, but we just couldn't get along. I developed a gambling problem because of depression. I would play cards all night with 6 other women and get up and go to work, take my daughter to daycare, and couldn't wait for the next card game. Meanwhile my husband still came home from work, lied down on the couch, get up to eat and then go to the gym. 5 days a week. I stopped gambling but started going out dancing and drinking. I met a man and started sleeping with him frequently. Everytime I went out I couldn't wait to be with him that night. I would leave sometime in the morning 2 or 3am and go home. (my husband was always very reserved about sex, and as I got older I knew I was more into sex then he was and was more open, but not with him). My relationship with the other man was never really sexually, even though we slept together, I never had an orgasm, I just wanted to feel close to someone. I wanted to feel loved.

I continued to see him whenever we would run into each other whether it be every six months or every year. In 1990 I had my son. I again would stay home hoping things would change between my husband and I but they wouldn't. Finially after 11 years of marriage I left for good. In June of 1995. This other man found a place for me to live with my children. A friend of his had a basement apartment in his house so I took it. My husband is only 5 minutes away from his kids and things are going good but I wonder if I never tried hard enough. My husband was verbally abusive, but was he justified because of my late nights and always wondering if I was sleeping with someone else. Or when he found out about my gambling and had to pay off the credit cards. I'm still seeing this other man but he just now seems like he might want to get married. We havn't talked about it by our selves but other people say it in a conversation. A year ago he would of said I'm not ready. Now he seems to be happy when someone mentions it. I don't bring it up because I think my daughter who is 11 years old still thinks me and her daddy will get back some day. Both my kids get along with my boyfriend, but we do not live together. I've never had to fake an orgasm with my boyfriend, he's very unselfish. He always makes sure he pleases me and vise versa. My husband always expected me to please him, but I never got anything in return. My boyfriend and I do more things with my children then my husband and me ever did.

"HERE COMES THE BUT" I always wonder if my husband was a different person, would I have had an affair, would I still be with him. Should I have told him how I felt sexually. I always told him everything else. But could never tell him about the sex. He used to stay completely away from me when I was pregnant because it turned him off and he said that some things he felt dirty about. What is dirty about 2 people who are suppose to love each other. My feelings now are when my boyfriend and I are fighting I really hurt, and I'm always the one to go to him so we don't go for too long without fighting. (something my husband and I did often, for weeks at a time.) Did I make the right choice, does it sound like my boyfriend really loves me. Should I have worked harder in my marriage. I feel like my relationship is coming to a different phase now and I'm scared. He's talking about buying a house together, but I'm not sure if I'm ready. Mostly because if I do I know its over with my husband and I even though so much time has passed. I really need some advice.

From: Bernd

First things first. You said “My husband was verbally abusive, but was he justified ..?” No; you may have played a part on the anger dance you both carried, but abuse is a choice - and you have no control over his choices. Abuse was an option he chose, out of a range of options; he had healthier ones to pick from too.

My guess is that the only way your husband could have been a different person is if YOU had been a different person, because I believe that we usually pick partners who provide the best mirrors for us - and those partners usually have faults and struggles which are mirror images of our own. Sometimes those mirrors are “Crazy House” kind of mirrors, but mirrors all the same.

And as much as you might wish YOU could have been different, “what is” is “what is”, And the same for “what was”. All the wishing in the world doesn’t change a thing. We are what we are, for whatever reason - even if we don’t understand why. Enough of the philosophy.:) I get carried away sometimes.

Your struggle right now makes a lot of sense to me. Maybe somewhere inside are little alarm bells ringing, and the fear of THIS relationship going down the tubes once you get married, like the last one? The commitment at this stage in your life HAS to feel like a big step; you want stability in your life for once, and in your kids’ lives. And no matter how good your relationship with your boyfriend is right now, at least you know what LIVING with your husband is like. Living with your boyfriend as a husband is still a very much “unknown” thing, no matter how much you might think you can predict it based on your present relationship with him. I sense a fear that “if I can’t figure out how to fix my first marriage, or let it go, how the heck am I gonna cope if a big problem pops up in the second marriage?”

I’m going to make one statement that I hope will help put things in a little perspective. You, and I have absolutely NO final control over whether a marriage works or not. We are able to control our input into the relationship, what we give and take, and how we do it. We could have all the virtues of Mother Theresa, and still end up divorced - because it’s up to our partner whether they want to be with us or not, and rational thinking does NOT have the final say in such decisions, as many know thru experience.

You made the best choices you could, with what you knew, and the baggage you carried (not of your own choosing) from your past. So did he. In my opinion, the word “marriage” really doesn’t matter on its own. What is most important to your happiness, and your kids, is what kind of “relationship” you have with your ex. It isn’t necessary to live with him, or be married to him, to have a great relationship. And you can have a super relationship with him even if you’re married to someone else. In fact, they complement each other very well.

What I hear is you have been used to defining your happiness and self-worth in terms of your main “relationship”. I suspect you feel inside that the failure of your first marriage, and the struggles you had in it, meant that there was something “wrong with you” - for eg., maybe you “didn’t try hard enough”, or wasn’t enough of this, or of that. As long as you define yourself this way, your marriage -past and present - will be both an Eden and a prison.

One of the things I discovered about love is that whatever is truly good for me is also truly good for Lynda. And vice versa. When I take the time to find out what my needs are, and take responsibility for them, and don’t try to “bargain” with them, things work out better than they ever did. Trying to make a partner “happy” usually means we focus more on trying to find out what their needs are, and become out of touch with our own. It backfires, because no matter how hard we try to please, somehow we end feeling like we got the short end of the stick sooner or later. It’s our own unmet, unacknowledged needs demanding our attention. When they yell loud enough, the most common thing to do is try and find the “quick fix” - an affair, gambling, etc. - which unleashes the trapdoor we pushed down for so long, and we end up gorging like a person who hasn’t eaten for what seems like forever.

One of the common things men do is to give up and withdraw when they feel like a failure. When a woman tries hard to “please her man”, often the man - who has been taught all his life NOT to feel too much emotion - feels overwhelmed, then feels guilty, then tries to even the scales, and finally gives up because of feelings of failure. This is not the woman’s fault, nor the man’s. It’s a dance they’ve both been taught all too well, and made to believe would bring them happiness. It’s a lie, something they discover all to well when that dance and many others they were taught take them from wedded bliss to divorce.

It took us many leaps of faith to practice taking responsibility for our OWN feelings first. This includes being honest with myself about what I want and what I need, finding ways of taking care of those needs that don’t obligate or hurt Lynda or anyone else, telling her what I want and need, and finding other ways of taking care of my needs when she isn’t ready, capable or willing. I found a way to get my “hug” need met when she didn’t want to be close, by getting them in my support group. I took care of my sexual needs when she was having her struggles with magazines, and believe it or not, hugs! (Non-sexual hugs seem to take care of some really deep inner needs that I had been using sex to fill before - a nice discovery!) I took care of my need to have my thoughts and feelings listened to, and validated, in my support group and with my therapist - and any friends I could corral to listen! I found there’s always more than one way to skin a cat, and often a dozen or more.:) By taking more responsibility for my needs, what I found is I wasn’t adding to Lynda’s weight like I used to, and she became more in touch with HER needs. Guess what? We discovered that we both pretty well wanted and needed the same things after all! We just didn’t know enough about how to listen to our own feelings before, or how many ways there were to safely take care of those needs with others, and with each other. Compared to the struggles we had with our needs before, things are so much EASIER now. It took leaps of faith, practice, and a lot of trial and error, but the rewards are permanent. I’m too old to keep these wheels inside my head going all day.:)

If you like reading, I’d recommend picking up any of the books I have listed in my Relationship Resources page, especially any on Codependency. Growing up in an alcoholic home has long-lasting effects, that very commonly show up later in adult relationships. You learned to dance from someone who danced with a bottle, and someone who was MARRIED to that person. It’s time to learn a different dance, one that doesn’t leave you stepping on each other’s toes all the time. Be with the one you chose, and let your soul help guide you in making that choice. But build a great relationship with both, by starting on building a new relationship with yourself. There’s no greater gift you can give your men, your kids, and yourself.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.