archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

I still love my husband - lost

After a year and a half of marriage and many problems my husband and I decided that we needed some time apart. Well, I shouldn't say me and my husband I should say "I decided" I moved to my own place and began to try and figure out what had happened. We began to talk again. I told him I still loved him and that we should give this marriage another try. After many tears he told me he though we should just be friends, as we were such good friends before we got romantically involved. He told me he still loves me very much but he can't take the chance of being hurt by me again. Through all of our problems before I was always the one who kept things together and now I can't understand how he can say that he is the one who is being hurt. I love my husband very much and would do anything to make our marriage work. The only thing is he doesn't want to try. How do I get him to try again? How do I know if he really doesn't want to try? Do I continue to tell him how much I love him and want our marriage to work or do I let things go? We're friends, we always have been, but how can I be his friend when I love him still? Please, anyone, I need help.

From: Bernd

You left him, and in his mind, he doesn’t see any real difference between the original commitment you made in your marriage vows, and the one you are trying to convince him of now. And I think it goes deeper than this, something that many men are terrified of deep inside: a fear that there’s something really defective inside of us, that means we’ll just get dumped again somewhere down the road, so what’s the use of trying???? It’s not worth the hurt.

No matter how good friends we are with someone, nothing tears away the walls of protection we’ve constructed faster than in-your-face real intimacy. As friends, we are able to have some sense of control over our emotional boundaries. In marriage, the “rules” are totally changed, and we’re naked, and vulnerable like we’ve never been before.

If you really want to be committed to this man, my sense is you have to fully support his - and your own - need to heal, and to make some sense out of the struggles you’ve had as a married couple, and both your feelings and thoughts during the split-up phase. A commitment to someone doesn’t mean you need to be married to them; it means valuing having them in your life, and sharing yourself and your time with them, and supporting their right to be themselves without pressure from us to change anything. It also means, in my opinion, accepting and asking their help in understanding them, and whatever ways we’ve hurt them. I suspect your partner has some very clear ideas as to what he feels he needs from you to chance another go at the marriage. He may not be willing to tell you what they are right now; he may not have faith that you’ll listen without judgment or defensiveness. You don’t have to agree with him however, to listen to him.

Can you tell me more about what you meant when you said you were always the one that kept things together? And can you also tell me what changed from the friendship to the marriage, and what problems you ran into during the first year of marriage?

My guess is that you won’t be able to recapture the type of friendship you had before, until you both come to more of a peace with what happened in the marriage. That marriage is now part of your history together, and that history didn’t exist BEFORE your initial friendship. You can’t go back now, you can only go forward.

My sense is that restoring the marriage is very much tied to building an even truer friendship than you had before. Remember what you liked about that friendship - being able to talk about anything, sharing your deepest feelings and thoughts, supporting each other emotionally. Those things are wonderful parts of friendship AND marriage. The phrase “I love/like you just the way you are” are also magical parts of friendship/marriage. When I feel unconditionally accepted by someone, I want to nuzzle up nice and close to them - it’s a natural instinct. Often in a marriage, that kind of acceptance gets sacrificed when we feel our partner isn’t meeting some important needs we have - we react with anger or hurt, and then our partner has the GALL to withdraw even more!:)

Anyway, I’m babbling. If you want this relationship to blossom again, my suggestion is let your partner know that you are okay with his fear, and his hesitation at risking again. Tell him you want to learn how to be a safe place for him again, and you want to learn how to tell him about your needs without sending the message he HAS to change for you to be happy with him. Let him know that you support his freedom to choose whether to share his life with you, or to move on - that you want what’s best for him, and that if what’s best for him is to share his life with someone else, you’ll support that with love. Share whatever time, and whatever parts of yourself and your life that feel good for you, and that he’s willing to share. Make your commitment a commitment to TODAY, and let tomorrow take care of itself. That’s what our relationship is based on - “today”. When I make the most out of our time today, and do that each day, “forever” takes care of itself quite nicely.:)

Hope something helped a little bit.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.