archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

I'm hurting too much to go on - Untrusting

Well, I just came back to work after the worst weekend of my life. Early Sunday morning (3:00 am) my sister and my fiancé of four years had sex. I found out on Sunday after my sister accused him of rape. There has been an investigation that has pretty much proven that there was no force involved and that both parties were willing. My sister is married with two kids and, I guess became afraid of someone finding out. I love my boyfriend and want to make it work out, but how can I trust him ever again. The pain is really to much for me to handle. I have lost a sister and all trust in the man I was to marry. Someone please, please help me!!! Thank you for any advice, comments, or stories of your own.

From: cindy

I'm sorry about your situation and I know this is very hard but I need a little more information about the circumstance surrounding the incidence. How did you find out, who told you and is your relationship with your sister a good one before this happened. Has your boyfriend been unfaithful before.

From: Bernd

Hang in there girl. That is rough. It crunches your heart right to the core when it's someone that close to you that is part of the betrayal.

From what we remember going thru our coping times, EVERY FEELING is normal and okay, as long as we don't harm ourselves or someone else by acting in unhealthy ways BECAUSE of our feelings - or lack of them. The cycles are similar, but very unique for everyone as well.

If you can find a place to scream and smash (or pound) something without hurting yourself, do it ASAP. There's a lot of rage inside, and venting it will help give some some needed strength to deal with the difficult days, weeks, and months ahead. One thing that helped me a lot during the hardest times was the phrase "and this too shall pass". Sometimes it's all that kept me from driving my car into a lamppost. I hope you find something to hang onto, and I hope you get the hugs and support you need here to help you thru this most difficult time.

From: Kim

First and foremost, you're safe to vent here. You have been injured by two people you trusted and loved and it is more than natural to feel just a little crazy right now. I know how much I hurt when I found about the 2 betrayals (sp?) in my life. You go through the grief process whether you work it all out or not.

I'm thinking of you and will say a special prayer that God gives you the gift of peace in your heart to handle whatever comes next. BIIIIIG HUG.

From: Susan

Don't let those two people destroy you....... Let it be enough that they have destroyed themselves. Probably none of us can say the right words to you right now - to tell you how much hurt we feel FOR you. Please come here and let out all that anger and rage and pain and sadness. We are here, we will support you with our thoughts and prayers. Hang on, please !!

From: Untrusting

Thank you all for your support and advice. Sometimes, it's not as hard as others--then it hits me "WHAM"! I'm glad I found this place OL.

In response to the questions asked: My sister and I were VERY close; we told each other everything. We live very close to each other (practically right across the street) and I was there, in the room with her, when her second child was born. I was given the honor of naming her and she will always be my little Cassandra. Now I'm afraid that I will never be able to see her or her sister. My whole family is torn apart by this. We were all so very close.

This happened Sunday Morning at around 3 a.m. I found out around noon the same day when my mother called me and asked me to come to her house because my sister, (we'll call her "Tina") had something to tell me. Tina sat me down and told me that my boyfriend had raped her. I was in SHOCK. I told her that if he had done that, that she needed to press charges. She said she couldn't go through the embarrassment. She told her husband next, and he said that she had to press charges, which is what she proceeded to do.

My family (mom, dad, brother, brother-in-law) were all on her side. My boyfriend admitted to me that he had had sex with her but swore it was not rape. The investigator talked to my sister and had her go to the hospital for rape examination. I have since found out that the forensic nurse could not come up with any evidence that it was a rape case. The investigator also came to my house to speak with my boyfriend. The investigator would NOT let me leave the room; he said I had a right to know and that he wanted my opinion on the story. So, I got to hear EVERY DETAIL!!--more than I ever wanted to know. My parents also heard both sides of the story......and have since then met with the investigator to tell him that their believe is that it was consensual--that's right, they don't believe my sisters story!

My boyfriend should feel lucky to ever have been included in my family. And, I hope he realizes this. My family still wants his to be a part of it, but the agree that we need counselling. I haven't spoken to my sister since Sunday. I do know that the investigator wants to see if she will take a lie-detector test, that she is refusing. And to top things off, as if I needed anything else, my brother-in-law is now making threats on my boyfriends life because he still believes that she was raped.

If I had time, and could slow my mind enough, to stop rambling, I'm sure this would all make more sense. I could also give you more details on how my sister "seduced" him and how he accepted her willingly. My mind isn't exactly straight now, and I am sorry. Thanks again, my new-found friends.

From: cindy

You have nothing to be sorry about, this is not your fault. They did it to you, you had nothing to do with it, and their was nothing to prevent this from happening. The thing that puzzles me is "why did your sister tell" was she threatened in any way by your boyfriend, or is she doing this all for attention, maybe guilt. You should know in your heart if it was RAPE. If in fact your boyfriend had any sexual hang-ups that might lead you to believe that this story is true. Go with your heart and don't let anyone make you believe something that you don't believe. You must be really hurting about now and I am so sorry your going through this BUT if it's answers you need and why, talk honest and open with both of them.

Ask your boyfriend if he wasn't satisfied with you, what made him stray, ask him to take a Lie Detector test and see how he reacts. By his reaction I think you'll get your answer as to who is lying. I cant say who is but the in your heart you will know in the end. If it ends up being your sister who is lying, and from what you've said so far, it's sound like she is, if you can go to her. Tell her you know she's not telling the truth and make her understand it's important to you to know why this happened. WHO KNOWS MAYBE THERE'S MORE TO THIS STORY THEN YOU THINK YOU KNOW AND WHAT BOTH PARTY'S ARE TELLING YOU. All and all your the only person who can determine if your relationship can be salvaged either with your boyfriend and sister or if in fact you will ever be able to trust either one again. My sympathy and prayers are with you.

From: mzet

I cannot begin to imagine the level of your pain. But I can feel at least some of your pain in my past pain. I am not an expert, but here are my guesses:

Vent all of your rage in ways that do not harm you or your sister or your boyfriend. I exercised a lot every day when I discovered my wife's affair. That helped tremendously. I cried a lot too. That helped a bunch and still does. But don't cry or vent rage in front of your sister or your boyfriend to "punish" them. Leave them alone in their own hell, particularly your sister's. Concentrate on your hell not theirs.

(By the way, this sexual encounter is probably more than just the sex. The sex may be the culmination of a mutual attraction that developed over time. They may be in love. In any event, they both also need time to sort out their hell. Give them the time and the space they need for that. )

Don't make any important decisions about your life, particularly your relationships, now. Don't make a decision about whether you want to salvage the relationship with your boyfriend now or not. Wait until you can be a little more rational about the possible outcome of that decision. Now is not the time for that.

Your healing will take time. But you will heal! Give yourself time, a lot of time. It took me over six months to get to a level where I could find peace. It may take you much longer.

Go to therapy for yourself first. That also helped me tremendously. In fact, everything that you do now should be FOR YOURSELF, not anybody else. After you have healed and after you decide if you want to continue your relationship with your boyfriend, then think about therapy to "salvage the relationship". Again, I feel it may be way too early for that.

Ask and get support from those around you, but remember that your parents are going through their own hell too. That's why a therapist is usually so good: someone outside who you can trust with your inner most feelings. Go to your local bookstore and buy a few books about affairs. They helped me, particularly in early on.

It's OK to feel what you feel: rage, anger, sadness, depression, suicidal, no appetite, vomiting, etc. I had them all. But you CAN channel those feelings towards a productive end. That's what I did. The whole mess (though not as intense as yours) gave me the opportunity to look inside of me for questions and answers about myself, irrespective of my wife's affair and her decisions and other outside circumstances.

Pain really gives you an opportunity to confront the source of that pain (which, oddly enough, is not what your sister and boyfriend did; that was just the trigger). The questions and the answers are inside of you, but you can't hear the whispers in the midst of this confusion. But over time and with discipline, you will. I hope this helps a bit. Hang in there. You are not alone. Take care of yourself.

From: hurting2

I feel for you. I am in the same situation. I was told by my sister in Feb. 97 that my husband had raped her not once but two times. I have been married for 16 years this month and have five children. His story is that that have been having an affair for 7 years and now I finding out about this almost 8 years after the fact. But I can tell you it probably hurts just as bad because for me everything in our marriage to me has been a lie. I will tell you to make sure that you want to be with this guy for the rest of your life, because to tell you the truth if I would have known years ago I would have left him. You will have good days and bad days. Today is a bad one for me. I have always been a strong person but this has torn me apart. I have I lost respect and trust for my husband but I have also lost a sister that I loved and her kids that I love. I am seeking some help at my church and I would hope that you go talk to someone too, it has been the only way I have been able to get through the week. I have many sleepless nights and I'm sure I will have more. But I can tell you that what I have learned is it always the response of the man to shut down and not want to talk about it. and that is what I am facing now. I would suggest that you make your boyfriend accountable and make him go with you to seek help for your relationship, if that is the direction your are heading in. Hang in there.

From: Untrusting

WOW! and I thought I was the only one something like this had happened to! My boyfriend has been willing to talk to me. Sometimes he gets upset and says that I am just trying to get the details so I can use them against him later, but I'm not. He also has taken full responsibility for this and wants to go to counselling with me.

You see so angry, hurting2, which I'm sure is normal. But it also frightens me because I was angry at first and now I just don't feel anything......just alone and confused. I'm wondering if this is normal to lack that anger? Thank you for letting me know that I am not alone.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.