archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Need Advice on Ultimatum - Amberle

I've written here before and always appreciate all the help. My question is in relation to my long-term relationship that seems to be stagnating. My boyfriend and I have been together 9 years now, monogamously. He recently admitted a mutual attraction with a woman where he works but told me repairing our relationship came first. (we had been growing apart). He finally told this woman back in Dec. that he wasn't going to cheat on me and wanted to try again with me. Just 2 weeks ago he went to a party and spent an hour telling her NO because she was drunk and told him "I want what our girlfriend has". He told her no, which makes me happy. He is "feeling better about us" which also makes me happy. If I could say anything to him, I would say "Marry me or get lost, because I'm tired of waiting." I would like an opinion on whether it is wise to issue this ultimatum or coast as we have been doing. To be fair, things between us have gotten a lot better and we have more fun in each other's company. We are both faithful and each other's best friends. So why can't I be patient? More importantly, should I? I'd hate issue an ultimatum hen have to say, oh well I didn't mean it! Any thoughts? Once again, thanks for reading!

From: Bernd

The more you need him to make choices and say things “which makes me happy”, the more something inside him is going to rebel at this responsibility. That’s the dance I see, and it’s one where both of you can’t AVOID stepping on each others’ toes. His part of the dance is that he gets the closeness and caring he wants from you in return. If he says something you don’t like, your pain and confusion makes you unavailable to him emotionally. If he says enough things you don’t like, he stands the real risk of losing you.

You want him to commit, but I suspect he sees commitment as the final stripping away of his freedom to make HIS choices and have HIS feelings. He’s used to trading off who he is to get the closeness he wants and needs, and my guess is you are familiar with seeing your worth and lovability as a reflection of how much your partner “loves” you. They are very much matching pieces (which ironically, makes perfect sense of why you’ve been together 9 years.)

This probably feels VERY risky, but if you want to take your relationship to a new level of closeness and commitment, those unaddressed issues have to come out, with the fears and pain that will be attached to them. But think of what you really want most. For example, what gift has most value - a gift he feels he SHOULD give you, or one he WANTS to give you, because it feels so good to him to give it? And with your own happiness, what feels better - being able to be happy even when he’s struggling with something, or only being able to be happy when you feel loved? My best assurance that I won’t have any major unpleasant surprises in our marriage is the freedom I “give” Lynda. Actually, I don’t give it,, because her freedom has always belonged to her. What I do is respect it and support it as much as possible, because it’s good for ME to do so. When she is making her choices based on what’s good for HER, I know her inner voice has the best chance of being heard. And that inner voice ALWAYS guides her toward loving choices.

It IS difficult and fearful supporting more of the freedom our partner wants inside. We have a natural fear of the unknown. And we see all sorts of terrible things happening in our crystal ball. The reality as well is that we’ll go thru our own withdrawal pains as we relinquish control over something that feels so important, while our partner stumbles blindly for a while trying to see if we are really serious about supporting more freedom, and then finding - to their horror - that it’s even HARDER being responsible to themselves for their choices. As much as they hunger for their freedom, they wish for the days when “you” told them what you wanted them to do. Be careful what you wish for.:) A good therapist can help in going thru this process. So does a LOT of talking, and a commitment to honesty, even when it’s scary.

If this sounds like something you want to explore further, you’ll find a lot of help in books and websites dealing with codependency. Do it for YOU, not for the “relationship”, or for him. Give him the freedom to decide how much he wants to be a part of your exploration. He’ll have his own fears and doubts about venturing into uncharted territory. The more you focus on you, the more freedom you’ll be giving him NATURALLY, as a result of your growth. My guess is that he’ll want to be a part of that growth process sooner or later, because HE wants to be just as happy in this relationship as you want to be.

Those are my best guesses.

From: Amberle

Once again, Bernd, you are on the money. I cried when I read what you said from simply (and finally) recognizing the truth of what you say. I've never been secure in myself, so how could I expect it from someone else? I know I have to find acceptance in myself first. I never was able to admit that until these troubles came into the open. I'm just so frustrated because he has the power right now in our relationship - it seems whatever he decides will be final. He doesn't want it that way; he even said he regrets that it is that way; but that doesn't change it. I love him more than he loves me. Do I try to draw back or do I continue giving more until there's nothing left? My patience with the whole situation is getting shorter.

From: Bernd

You said "it seems whatever he decides will be final". He only has power over HIM, and his half of the relationship. It's a risk choosing what is best for YOU, and then making an appropriate choice - but the actual risks are even greater when you let HIM chart out which way you go.

It takes practice and little steps to do something new. Empowering yourself is no different. Take the time you need to get a feel for what is best for you in each situation, and try to stay away from making any decisions until you have some sense of what is best for you. Unless someone's life is at stake, no decision needs to be made before you're ready.

Also, focus on learning, rather than "becoming better". Change often means 3 steps forward, and 4 steps back at first, and this is natural. Our "mistakes" teach us some valuable lessons, and the more you can accept your "mistakes" as just another class in life 101, the less guilt and shame will cloud your vision.

As painful as it might be sometimes, we don't learn how to wrestle alligators to the ground by standing behind the fence. The swamp is really the only place to get the hands-on-learning. Take breaks (distance) as often as you need, and want. And build as much as a support network as you can. Other people have learned how to wrestle those gators, and they are only too glad to help you make it safely thru to the other side.

When and if it's time to leave this relationship, the more you can make that choice with some calmness inside, the less likely it will be that you'll repeat those struggles in your next relationship. Those are my best guesses. Keep searching for what is best for YOU, and you'll find it, step by step.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.