archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

What do women want? - maelstrom

For years I was the stereo typical "nice guy", trying to get to know the lady first, trying to make her feel comfortable with me and secure before I pursue anything. All I have gotten from this approach is " Oh, your such a good friend " or " Wow, your such a nice guy I'll help you find a girl ". Meanwhile I see my friends with beautiful girls , and watch them treat these women like shit and the women still hang around. I've talked to alot of women about this subject, and most of them tell me that they would love to have a man that treats them a nicely as I do. Is this true? Do women really want nice guys , or is this just a fallacy?

From: Kim

Okay. This is not going to be some insightful reply, just a basic feeling that I have on the subject. For me, I love to be with a "nice" guy, BUT it's nice to know that underneath all of the politeness there is a simmering pot of passion that he is controlling. Kind of like "if I weren't such a nice guy I would want to be somewhere else with you right now....." Now that's probably my codependency talking, but I think alot of women have a similar feeling, though it may not be healthy.

Remember though, just because a woman wants the man to feel attracted in a very passionate way, doesn't mean that she doesn't appreciate or want him to be a real and caring man. I have alot of passion when I am "in-love" with the guy I'm with AND I try and be nice and appropriate with it too. It's kind of like an undercurrent of excitement. It's there, but you don't have to act on it every moment......but it keeps them guessing what will come next. I guess it's just fun!

I don't know if this is what you're talking about, but I thought I'd share it with you. Good luck. There are healthy women out there who want a REAL man like you and not a game player.

From: Amberle

Well, I can tell you what this woman wants. I want respect, passion, and friendship. I would never be with my boyfriend if he weren't my best friend. *Any* best friend would respect the other, regardless of the gender. So I think you should be proud of being "nice"; it's not a "four-letter word". It's the right way to be. And who wants to be with a woman who wants to be treated badly? You shouldn't. Luck to you.

From: Kit

Well,.... I will be very honest with you. the fact that you are a nice guy is not a problem in women's eyes. The fact that you see your friends with all these beautiful women that they treat like dirt is because SOME women like a challenge. A little something to keep the excitement and competition going.

Women sure as hell don't like to be TREATED like shit. That just has a tendency to get out of hand in some cases.

Don't EVER stop being a "nice guy". My advice to you is to not make yourself seem so available and interested. Don't be a typical guy about it - but just be subtle. Don't give TOO much information about your feelings - just a bit here and there - but at least that much. Don't wear it thin too soon. Take it a little bit at a time. If you spark a woman's curiosity about you, it's a sure attention grabber. Try to stray from becoming the girls friend BEFORE you pursue her. But become her friend AS you pursue her. I know that my friends are very important to me. If I were to date one of them and it didn't work out, I would have lost something in that friendship forever. I hope this makes SOME kind of sense. If I could explain how us women are and why we are the way we are, I would be a genius. I can't even figure us out. But - the best of luck to you. Just don't ever fall from the "nice guy" label, just to get a girl. There are those of us out there who are looking for nice guys.

From: Bernd

I don't know if you can identify with any of my experiences, but I thought I'd tell you a bit about what I went thru. I tried to be a nice guy, but interpreted that to mean I should be extra sensitive to the girl's feelings, and cautious about almost every move I made.

As a result, I was passive, and very out-of-touch with what was best for ME. I longed for closeness, but was too timid to risk rejection. By the time I DID get up the nerve, the "relationship" had become uncomfortable for them. They sensed a need in me that felt smothering to them (and it was), and distanced themselves. I went thru a lot of rejections because of this dance.

If I had the insights I do now, I would do the dating game a lot different. I would focus on what felt good and healthy for me first, because if I'm not in touch with my own feelings and needs - and doing what I need to take good care of them - how in the world can I ever be in touch with my partner's needs and feelings? The more in touch I am with myself, the more I can be ME - not someone I hope Lynda will like. It seems more risky, but it isn't. Those are my thoughts.

From: cindy

I think these women who like "abusive men" are in a Challenge mode. If you read my listing on abusive men and why my girlfriend is with one when she has so much going for her, I just can't understand it. All her 34 years she has dated NICE MEN then finially a real Rotten Apple shows up in her life and she stays with him. I think women find nice men boring and no challenge, they need something else to keep things interesting. The problem is they don't realize what's ahead until it's to late. You can call it low self-esteem or whatever but the fact remains women will be attracted to these kind of men until we stop letting them treat us like they do. ANOTHER THING, MEN ONLY DO WHAT US WOMEN LET THEM. I'VE BEEN THERE. I JUST GOT SO TIRED I LEFT.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.