archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Questioning Everything - Steve02

Lately I've been becoming more and more in the mood of questioning every single, tiny action and/or thought my g/f displays to me. I act like this due to the fact that she says one thing, yet does another (whether it be positive vs. negative or vice versa). When I say everything, I mean "everything". She says she doesn't want to hold my hand, yet 10 min. later, she's the one reaching for my hand. I get confused and question it. I don't question here due to wanting to avoid a confrontation (after all, if she's going to sit there and say NO more attention Steve, but then she turns around and actually does it, sure, I'm gonna soak it all up!) and I'd look stupid asking her "why are you holding my hand?". I question myself. I try to read her actions and convert them into thoughts and it becomes quite frustrating. I feel that either I shouldn't care and just accept that fact that I do get attention (but only when she gives it, not when I seek it or ask for it) and quit questioning it or I feel that I should keep on questioning it as I'm onto some trail she's leading me and I soon I'll figure out just what the hell she's talking about. So, there's my 2 cents (again) on my relationship - and what a confusing one it is.

From: Claudia

Steve, To me it sounds like an issue of control. Perhaps inability to receive your reaching to her, perhaps she wants to feel "in charge". Kinda like giving but not allowing oneself to get.

From: Bernd

“I feel that either I shouldn't care and just accept that fact that I do get attention (but only when she gives it, not when I seek it or ask for it) and quit questioning it or I feel that I should keep on questioning it as I'm onto some trail she's leading me and I soon I'll figure out just what the hell she's talking about.”

I find women are much more in touch with their emotions, but have just as difficult time as us men do finding out WHY they feel a certain way at a certain time. Many of them have also been told they’re stupid (or had that impression reinforced). So when their partner asks them to explain what’s going on inside them, it often 1/sets off waves of even more confusion inside the woman, because SHE isn’t really sure why she feels good about holding hands one moment, but not the next 2/when she can’t explain why, she feels “stupid” again 3/gives her the unspoken message that “she’s” creating yet another problem, just by being herself 4/gives her the clear message that risking intimacy is going to put her thru #1 and #2 over and over again.

Steve, as much as you want to figure out your partner, you are on the OUTSIDE of her body and mind, not on the inside. It’s hard enough understanding your own feelings, and finding healthy and loving ways to express them - and you’re on the INSIDE of YOUR body and mind. If you want to get a better understanding of what’s going on inside her, you can only do that by getting a better understanding of what goes on inside YOU, when you feel angry and frustrated because of her choices.

With Lynda, I’ve discovered that whatever she’s freely willing to give, is always what I need most. If she takes my hand one moment, and lets go of it the next, I’m ok with that. There’s a good reason behind her choice, whether I understand it or not. I don’t NEED to understand why to accept it, and be comfortable with it. I can simply accept it, and find other healthy and honest ways of taking care of needs I have that she isn’t ok helping with right now. In fact, it’s my need to understand HER before I can let go of my turmoil, that causes my struggles and frustration. The more I accept her from moment to moment, the calmer and quieter I become inside - and ironically, that’s when I learn the MOST about her. It’s like being in a crowded classroom (my head), with everyone talking, and trying to learn from what the teacher’s saying. I can’t because there’s so much noise. Once things quiet down, I’m able to listen in a way I never could before, and the answers I’ve been looking for just seem to come on their own.

You don’t have to stop caring to “accept that fact that I do get attention only when she gives it, not when I seek it or ask for it’. In fact, giving such acceptance is VERY caring thing to do.

“I feel that I should keep on questioning ...”. I agree. Question YOURSELF about YOUR feelings, not her about hers. That’s where you’ll find the answers, as crazy as that might sound. When you find yourself going around in circles trying to figure out why you feel a certain way in certain situations, reach out for other people’s insights. This comment forum is a safe place to do that. The more you focus on finding solutions to your struggles without needing anything from her that she isn’t freely willing to give, the safer she’ll feel with you, and the more likely it is she’ll risk sharing her guesses about her own feelings with you. Those are my thoughts and guesses. Hope something helps.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.