archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Her feelings still haven't changed - Tom

Was searching the old posting and found MY thread! Wow...hope it helps someone else. To continue my sage, my wife STILL says she's in love with him, yet they haven't communicated since mid June (about 2 months). She says she's lost "those" feelings for me and isn't sure if they'll ever come back. She says she wants them to and for us to have a great marriage, but her feelings just aren't there. I'm getting SO frustrated. You were right. This is tough love.

Somedays (like right now) I feel like divorcing her. She said if the tables were turned and she would divorce me! She can't understand why I want to stay together. Is there hope? Perhaps. I just don't want to live my entire married life with just a roommate. I need to be in love with my wife and I demand the same back. How long will I wait with the status quo before giving up the ship? I don't know. I'm going TDY (Temporary Duty...I'm in the AF) for 90 days starting in October. When I get back in January, hopefully she'll have worked out some of her feelings... Thanks again!

From: Claudia

Tom, Love is not something that can be demanded.

From: really?

Love can be demanded. It just may not be granted.

From: Tom

I agree you can't demand love. My wife has to give it to me. I cannot take it from her. That's obvious.

From: patience

Tom, you have a lot of patience, don't you? You also have a lot of understanding. That is good. Let me say some comments about some thoughts about the posting you have made online. It is unrealistic to think that the "old" feelings will come back, because they are long and gone. You should try not to live in the past. The past is gone, and you can remember it, and you can learn from it. However, it is the future that you should try to work on during this moment called the "present". This is where you have the ability to make choices on what you are going to say, on what you are going to do, and on what you are going to react to.

It is in this moment that you can react to outside stimuli, or you can observe outside stimuli and then decide how you will react. You can explain to your wife that you are still married to her because you want it to work out with her, and that you love her, and that you want to stick by her even through hard times. You can explain to her that you married her because ( you fill in the blanks) and can also try to list all of the good times that you have had. In your own life, you can think about how you used to feel and how you used to talk to her when things were going well, and there was "love" feelings. You can compare that past to the way that you have been recently treating her, and try to see if you speak to her in a different tone of voice or in a different way with different emphasis and different gestures. It may be that you are treating her in ways that before you would "never" have because before you were so much in love with her.

It is a good thing if you can try to build up her self-esteem by telling her all of the things that you like about her, and about all of the things that you are thankful in relation to the times that you have spent with her. You can tell her that you appreciate her for (you fill in the blanks), and can mention that you would like to (you fill in the blanks). It may also be good to try to see if she is interested in re-developing a future "dream" for your life, which may include moving to another location or "settling" down in some place to get to know each other again. The more that you build her self-esteem the more that she will feel comfortable to "re-kindle" the old feelings that she had. She may feel very guilty about what she has done, and she may not feel very good inside about the whole situation. The more that you can help her to feel loved, appreciated, and so on, the better the chances are that you can get over the things that happened in the past. The more that you try to make her feel bad about what happened and the more that you try to make her feel guilty, the more that she will build up an emotional wall in between you.

The reason is that it may be too painful for her emotionally to get in "touch" with her love feelings for you because then she may need to get in "touch" with her guilt feelings as well. If you can somehow build up her self-esteem and make her feel good, then those guilt feelings will become less powerful, and she will feel that it is safe to get in touch with her good feelings for you and you will be able to have a better relationship than you have had before. Try to find out more about how to develop good communication skills, and how to build up her self-esteem. If you have friends that have good communication skills in their intimate relationships, then talk with them and see if they have any suggestions that can help you. It may be difficult to bring "back" the old feelings that she had for you, though it is not impossible. It is in fact possible to develop "new" feelings, meaning that if you can figure out what it was that you did to make her fall in love with you when you originally got married, then you may be able to "do that again", and make her fall in love with you again.

If you think about it, you probably did do some things differently than you have recently been doing, and you may want to consider that. There are some other things that may help. One is to find a "love" doctor or "love" expert who knows how to kindle love feelings between couples. This kind of "doctor" is different than the doctor who tries to sort through all of the problems in a relationship. This doctor will simply use techniques to bring love back into the relationship, and to help couples to fall in love with each other again. Some people think of Barbara D'Angelos. You might try her, or someone else who you believe is qualified. It may be helpful to read some books, though if you are serious about it, you should go talk with the love doctor in person with your SO.

From: Tom

I agree I can't live in the past...but I want a future I can look forward to. We've talked about staying/divorcing a LOT together. We've come to the mutual conclusion we should stay together and try to make it work...mainly for the children's sake, but we both want to be happy.

Reflecting upon my recent behaviors, I have been really depressed and probably not myself. She hasn't either. This is hard for both of us. She's still in love with another man and that drives me crazy. I've been a lot more moody. Although I've been taking her out a lot, buying her flowers, etc. Generally, we are getting along great except at the one-on-one level... Maybe that's not a good way of describing it. We hold hands, kiss and hug...but not much more. Sex is completely out of the question right now... She doesn't want me that way and THAT strikes me to my core...but I'm trying to cope with it as best I can.

As far as moving, etc...I'm in the AF and can only move when the AF says I can move. That will happen again next summer and we'll leave Germany (Thank GOD for that). We just sold our home in Indiana so we aren't committed to living in any one place in particular. We'll see how we like it at our next assignment.

I'd LOVE to find a "love doctor" but my choices are severely limited in Germany...especially when the local doctors all speak German and we don't! I don't know if they do consulting over the internet, but I would consider it. Waiting until next summer may be too late.

From: Bernd

Tom, Are there any counseling services available on base? If there are, do you have reservations about using them?

Lynda and I struggled with pretty much the same thing (although each situation is unique). The pent-up release she had with her boyfriend of so many of her feelings, was still a fresh memory. The contrast between how caged she had felt in our marriage, versus that freedom, continued to be one of her struggles. Added to that was the confusion and guilt she felt over what she had done, and the strong feelings she continued to have for this man. I’m going to ask you to put yourself in another pair of shoes for a second, and think about how it would feel if SHE said to you “get over it, and act like a man”. Does that bring some anger up? If so, that anger would make it next to impossible to sort out other struggles and feelings you have. I suspect she is finding it next to impossible as well to really sort out what’s going on inside of her, because your depression, pain, and need for her to work things thru to take care of YOUR feelings add weight to an already unbearably heavy load she’s carrying with her OWN struggles. You both are in a lot of pain, and to get close to you means that SHE will have to feel your pain as well as hers (this is a natural part of intimacy, not something you’d “force” her to do).

If you had a huge difficulty in your job that continued to frustrate you, I suspect you’d search for someone with the knowledge and experience to help you resolve it. It may take a little bit more digging to use the same approach in your marriage, but asking yourself what the stakes are will help you get a better feel for the amount of effort that’s worthwhile putting into such a search. There ARE answers and solutions to what you and your wife are going thru. To find them may mean a commitment unlike any you’ve ever made before. Think of being involved in an investigative team looking at why an AF jet crashed. Would you be satisfied with leaving any stone unturned to make sure the disaster didn’t happen again - ESPECIALLY if you were the pilot of a similar jet? In a similar way, the more you learn about why your marriage is having such struggles right now - and what solutions will really work - the better chance you have of not crashing again. There’s one big difference between your marriage and a plane - your marriage won’t “kill” you even when it feels like it’s on a dizzying dive.

I’d suggest hitting the bookstores - including online ones if there aren’t any good English ones nearby - and reading everything you can on relationships and marriage. Look at them as “counselors” on your night table. Also, this kind of exploration is almost impossible to do alone. Search out other men at your base who you feel have integrity, and trustworthiness, and ask one to be your mentor. The best kind is someone older, who has a sound marriage, and is willing to share their experiences and insights. This person will be invaluable to you, giving you reality checks on your own progress, as well as validating your own worthiness and giving you a safe place to let off steam. Yes, there is a risk here, but “no risk” can also be the highest risk.

Thirdly, do whatever you can to take the edge off of your sexual frustration (besides infidelity). I don’t know if you feel guilty or angry when you think about fantasizing having sex with imaginary partners, but I found it helped me a lot in taking the edge off. Our imagination is a safe place, because thoughts aren’t choices. We only get into trouble when we want to turn our imagination into reality. I’m not suggesting this is a substitute for sex in the marriage; all I’m saying is that whatever you can do to give yourself good sexual feelings will help you in reducing your turmoil and dependency on your wife right now. The more weight you can take off her shoulders as far as your needs, the better chance she has of focusing on HER internal struggles, and finding some answers that will benefit both of you.

Our marriage started to turn around once I stopped focusing so much on what Lynda wasn’t giving me, and began exploring how to take better care of MY needs. We’ve all grown up using love partly as a drug (pain-killer) and partly as the real thing. It’s really hard for us to see when we’re doing the first, until we get more insight from others (either thru their written words, or spoken ones). Instinctively, something inside us “knows” when we’re being used as a drug; when it happens, something in our system shuts down our feelings, and throws a wall up to protect us. The longer we’ve been in a relationship, the harder it becomes to push that wall back down inside. What helps us most is having our partner discover what things they are doing and needing that are part of using us as a pain-killer, and finding ways to turn those into genuine, caring and compassionate love. Both partners win whenever this happens. So do the kids, in huge ways. You break some of the balls and chains that were handed you, and give your kids a MUCH better chance of having a happy marriage themselves, from what they learn from your example.

You can’t do it alone Tom. You’ve discovered that already. I hope you find the courage and hope you need to do the searching that will bring you to the doorway that leads to real happiness in your marriage - for you, your wife and your children.

From: Cindi

There is a group on line that deals with extra-marital affairs. The BAN group. Http://www.vaughan-vaughan.com/index.html. They are both PHDs. You have to have a membership, but it is nothing more than an online request form they have. I have joined, but just recently, so I cannot give you an opinion yet. But I have read the posts and it has helped me to identify with others who has been down the same road.

Hang in there, the old saying "This too will pass" is true. We don't always get want we want in life, but we usually get what we need. The problem is we usually resist what we need, kicking and screaming all the way. Do what you need to do to take care of you, do what you can do as a couple to take care of the relationship. The rest is out of your control. I have been where you are now, and I hated it at time, but it turned out to be one of the best things that happened to me.

From: mzet

Tom, I haven't had a chance to read all of your story. I KNOW EXACTLY HOW YOU ARE FEELING, my wife started an affair a year ago. She finally broke it off in May but had a second affair with another man immediately after. She broke off with the second guy in late July.

It took her many months, essentially from December 96 until May 97 to break off with the first guy, and perhaps it took the second affair to get the first guy off her mind. The second guy was much easier. But know she still misses the thrill of freedom she felt with the affairs. This is hard to do. Remember that your wife is really in love. There a chemical changes in the brain that take place when you fall in love. Your whole life shifts, you feel free, empowered, invulnerable, etc. It is hard to break from that type of thrill. I have said before that it is just like an addiction. It is tough to be sober again. Give her time, more time, as much time as you can. Give her space, more space, as much space as you can.

I also have not had any sex, since January to be exact, not even a kiss, but I have been able to somehow temper my sexual desire. In fact, that is now secondary to other more pressing needs I feel I have, such as intimacy, holding hands, hugging, talking, playing together, going out with her, etc. What I have done to temper sex has been to try to concentrate on answering why the hell I need sex so badly that it tarnishes what I am trying to accomplish, which is to work on the relationship. I know that when I ask for sex it turns her off completely, so I only do it in indirect gentle ways and only once every other week or so, and I don't blow up when I am rejected, which is very hard to take, especially in the beginning. To me, sex is only the icing on the cake, great to have, but you need the cake first.

I had sex about five times a week with my wife for twelve years, plus, since I just couldn't get enough, I used pornography regularly, so it was extremely difficult to get used to no sex, but it is possible. This will sound strange: Fasting within the context of prayer has helped me tremendously. In giving up food in a limited and controlled way and within the context of a spiritual life, in tempering my hunger, I think I have been able to temper my sexual desire. It's as if fasting shifted my mental energy from feeling frustrated about sex to feeling my hunger and consciously controlling it rather than it controlling me, and in turn, that has allowed me to use the same experience to control sexual desire. The link is not direct, but I believe it is there. In fact, I didn't start fasting to control sex, but it has been an added benefit. And like I always say, this has been my solution and only my solution, I am not saying you or anybody else should try it, but so far it has worked for me. I feel a lot more freedom now than before. I'm not constantly thinking about sex and I can concentrate better at work, the kids, play time for myself, etc. But most importantly, this has taken a load out of our relationship...

I constantly feel like divorcing my wife too. She also says she would have left me a long time ago if she were me, that she doesn't understand how I can still love her, that she doesn't love me, etc. But I think we should keep in mind that our wives hate themselves for having done this and for many other reasons we don't' understand and they have not begun to explore, so they can't stand why we just don't hate them also. I take this whole mess a day at a time. I don't dwell on how long I feel I can take. I don't have a deadline. It might be a year or a day or ten years, I don't know. I tell her I wish she would just say I WANT this to work out. I don't ask for an I WILL or an I CAN make this work, but more an I WANT. She hasn't given it yet. I have told her that until she makes that step, any attempt to try to have love rekindled will be futile. It just won't "happen". You have to want it first. Then you are opening up to the possibility of that gift to be discovered.

Sometimes I feel that life with my wife as a roommate will be better than a divorce. We have four small kids and it breaks my heart for them to be living with divorced parents. Sometimes I feel a divorce will be best for me, so I can just go out and get my life back together. It is very frustrating to be going back and forth. And I don't know what the best answer is.

So right now I just live in an expectant mode, waiting in silence for God to do His thing, whatever that may be. I am ready for whatever comes. I hate the wait, and perhaps that's what God now wants. God knows I can take a divorce or a good marriage, but that this current situation is causing a lot of pain. Maybe, just maybe, that's what He wants for now.

Anyway, there are no easy answers. But if I concentrate on myself, things get better, regardless of what the eventual outcome will be. The less I try to concentrate on trying to fix the marriage, the more it gets fixed, however slowly. The more I concentrate on trying to fix myself rather than my wife, the more she fixes herself, however slowly. Life is a lag. :) My guesses anyway, take care.

From: Cuckold

Tom I feel for you. Your wife staying with you is a positive sign. Your wanting to make love to your wife is only natural. I tried it the night I found out about her affair. I don't think it helped matters much.(She divorced me and is still with him)

I told her I loved her tried to do what I thought she wanted me to but she didn't know what she wanted. If I could do it over again I really don't know what I would do, but trying to react to her would be high up on the list. She later claimed all kinds of things I never did for her. Any way it takes time to recover from affairs ... a long time... but if she is still there the chance to make a better marriage is there. hang in there


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.